Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching Portuguese grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about Por que você está triste hoje?
Why does the sentence use Por que instead of Porquê?
Por que (two words) is used in questions when it means why or for what reason, especially in direct or indirect questions. Porquê (one word) is most commonly used as a noun meaning the reason. In this sentence, we’re asking Why are you sad today?, so Por que is correct.
Why do we say você está instead of tu estás?
In Brazilian Portuguese, você is the most common way to say you (singular), regardless of whether you know the person well or not. Tu is still used in some regions, but across most of Brazil, você is preferred.
Why do we say está instead of é?
In Portuguese, estar is used for states or conditions that are temporary or subject to change, such as feelings or moods. Ser, on the other hand, is used for more permanent characteristics or identities. Since being sad is usually a temporary state, está is appropriate here.
Can I shift the word hoje earlier, like Por que você hoje está triste?
It’s grammatically possible but somewhat unnatural in everyday speech. In Portuguese, placing hoje at the end (Por que você está triste hoje?) flows more naturally. You’ll still be understood if you move it, but it may sound a bit odd or overly formal.
Do I need to include hoje if it's obvious we are talking about today?
Not necessarily. If the context makes it clear that you’re referring to today, you can simply say Por que você está triste? and people will still understand you. However, including hoje emphasizes that we’re talking about this specific day.
Your questions are stored by us to improve Elon.io
You've reached your AI usage limit
Sign up to increase your limit.