Breakdown of Ona długo nie mogła się zdecydować, który fotel postawić przy oknie, a który przy lampie.
Questions & Answers about Ona długo nie mogła się zdecydować, który fotel postawić przy oknie, a który przy lampie.
Why is ona included? Could Polish just say Długo nie mogła się zdecydować...?
Yes. Polish often drops subject pronouns when the verb already shows who the subject is.
- nie mogła already tells you the subject is she because mogła is feminine singular past tense.
- So Długo nie mogła się zdecydować... is completely natural.
Including ona adds emphasis or contrast, for example:
- Ona długo nie mogła się zdecydować, ale on od razu wiedział.
So ona is not required here, but it is possible.
Why is it mogła and not mógł or mogło?
What does długo mean here, and where can it go in the sentence?
Długo means for a long time or long in this context.
So:
- Ona długo nie mogła się zdecydować = She couldn’t decide for a long time.
Its position is fairly flexible. For example:
- Ona długo nie mogła się zdecydować
- Długo nie mogła się zdecydować
- Nie mogła się długo zdecydować
All are possible, though they may differ slightly in emphasis.
Why is it nie mogła się zdecydować? What does zdecydować się mean exactly?
The verb is zdecydować się na coś or simply zdecydować się, meaning to decide or more literally to make up one’s mind.
In this sentence:
The się is part of the verb expression. You should learn it together:
- zdecydować się = to decide
- decydować się = to be deciding / to decide (imperfective)
So this is not just zdecydować by itself in the same sense; the reflexive form is the normal one here.
Why is się in the middle: mogła się zdecydować? Could it be mogła zdecydować się?
Yes, both are possible:
- mogła się zdecydować
- mogła zdecydować się
But się often appears early in the clause, and mogła się zdecydować sounds very natural.
Polish word order is flexible, but short unstressed words like się often avoid standing at the very beginning of a clause and frequently come near the verb.
So the sentence as written is standard and natural.
Why is it który fotel and not jaki fotel?
This is a very common learner question.
- jaki fotel? = what kind of armchair? / what sort of armchair?
- który fotel? = which armchair? (from a known set of options)
In this sentence she is choosing between specific armchairs and deciding where to place each one, so który is correct:
- który fotel postawić przy oknie, a który przy lampie
- which armchair to put by the window, and which by the lamp
Why is the verb postawić used? Why not stawiać?
Because postawić is perfective and refers to a completed action: to place / to put down.
Here she is deciding about a specific result:
- which armchair to place by the window
- which one to place by the lamp
That makes the perfective verb natural.
Compare:
- postawić = to place, to put down once, with completion
- stawiać = to be placing, to place repeatedly, habitually, or without focusing on completion
So który fotel postawić... means which armchair to place..., not a repeated or ongoing action.
Why is it fotel? Doesn’t that mean more like armchair than chair?
Yes. Fotel usually means armchair or easy chair, not an ordinary chair.
Compare:
- krzesło = chair
- fotel = armchair
So the sentence is specifically about armchairs, not regular chairs.
Why is it przy oknie and przy lampie? What case is that?
The preposition przy takes the locative case when it means by, next to, or near.
So:
- okno → przy oknie
- lampa → przy lampie
That is why the endings change.
Examples:
- przy stole = by the table
- przy drzwiach = by the door
- przy oknie = by the window
Why does okno become oknie and lampa become lampie?
Because they are in the locative singular after przy.
Here are the base forms and the locative forms:
- okno → oknie
- lampa → lampie
This is a normal case change in Polish noun declension.
So:
- przy oknie = by the window
- przy lampie = by the lamp
You do not need to translate the case ending directly into English; it is just how Polish marks the noun after this preposition.
Why is there a który przy lampie instead of repeating the whole phrase a który fotel postawić przy lampie?
Because Polish often leaves out words that are easy to understand from context.
The full version would be:
- który fotel postawić przy oknie, a który fotel postawić przy lampie
But that sounds repetitive, so Polish naturally shortens it to:
- który fotel postawić przy oknie, a który przy lampie
The missing parts are understood:
- a który [fotel postawić] przy lampie
English does the same:
- which armchair to put by the window, and which by the lamp
What does a mean here? Is it just and?
Here a connects two contrasted parts:
- which armchair by the window
- and which by the lamp
It is often translated as and, but it has a slight contrastive feel, something like:
- and which one by the lamp
- while which one by the lamp
- and which one, on the other hand, by the lamp
In many contexts, a links two parallel or contrasted ideas more naturally than i.
Why is który in the form który? Shouldn’t it change case?
It is functioning with fotel, and here the phrase is effectively the object of postawić:
- który fotel postawić = which armchair to place
Normally that would be accusative. But fotel is masculine inanimate, and for masculine inanimate nouns, the accusative singular looks the same as the nominative singular.
So:
- nominative: który fotel
- accusative: który fotel
They look identical here, even though the function is object-like.
Could the sentence use ustawić instead of postawić?
Yes, in some contexts it could, but the nuance changes a bit.
- postawić = to put, set down, place
- ustawić = to position, arrange, set in place
If the focus is simply putting the armchairs somewhere, postawić works well. If the focus is arranging them in a certain layout, ustawić might sound more natural.
So both can be possible, but postawić is perfectly normal in this sentence.
Is this sentence literally saying she could not decide which armchair to place where?
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PolishMaster Polish — from Ona długo nie mogła się zdecydować, który fotel postawić przy oknie, a który przy lampie to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions