Breakdown of W tej księgarni szukam powieści, której autora bardzo lubi moja siostra.
Questions & Answers about W tej księgarni szukam powieści, której autora bardzo lubi moja siostra.
Why is it w tej księgarni?
Because w means in here, and when w indicates location, Polish uses the locative case.
- księgarnia → księgarni in the locative singular
- ta → tej to match the noun
So:
- w tej księgarni = in this bookshop
Why is it szukam powieści and not szukam powieść?
Because the verb szukać normally takes the genitive case in Polish.
So:
- dictionary form: powieść
- genitive singular: powieści
That is why you get:
- szukam powieści
This is something learners often just have to memorize with the verb:
- szukać kogoś / czegoś = to look for someone / something
Does powieści mean singular or plural here?
By itself, powieści is ambiguous. It can be:
- genitive singular of powieść
- or nominative/accusative plural
But in this sentence it is singular.
The clearest clue is której, which is feminine singular and refers back to powieści. So the sentence is talking about one novel, not several.
If it were plural, you would expect something like:
- powieści, których autorów...
Why is it której?
Której is a form of the relative pronoun która / który / które.
It refers back to powieści, so it must match that noun in:
- gender: feminine
- number: singular
But its case is determined by its role inside the relative clause, not by the main sentence.
Here it means something like:
- the novel whose author...
- literally: the novel, the author of which...
That is why Polish uses której here rather than która.
Why is it której autora, not którą autora?
Because której does not depend on szukam. It belongs to the relative clause.
Main clause:
- szukam powieści = I am looking for a novel
Relative clause:
- której autora bardzo lubi moja siostra = whose author my sister likes very much
Inside that relative clause, której shows possession/connection: author of the novel. So it needs the form used for of which / whose, not the form for a direct object.
So:
- którą would be wrong here
- której is correct
Why is it autora and not autor?
Because autora is the direct object of lubi.
The verb lubić takes the accusative case:
- lubić kogo? co?
For masculine animate nouns, the accusative singular often looks the same as the genitive singular.
So:
- autor = nominative
- autora = accusative singular here
That is why:
- moja siostra lubi autora = my sister likes the author
Is autora genitive or accusative here?
It is accusative here, even though it looks like genitive.
Why the confusion? Because masculine animate nouns in Polish often have:
- genitive singular = autora
- accusative singular = autora
In this sentence, autora is the thing being liked, so grammatically it is the accusative object of lubi.
Why is moja siostra at the end?
Because Polish word order is much more flexible than English word order.
The basic grammar is still clear because the case endings show who is doing what:
- moja siostra is nominative, so it is the subject
- autora is accusative, so it is the object
Putting moja siostra at the end gives it a bit of focus, as if the speaker is highlighting who likes the author.
Other orders are possible too, for example:
- ..., której autora moja siostra bardzo lubi.
That sounds a bit more neutral. The original version is perfectly natural.
Why is there a comma before której?
Because in Polish, relative clauses introduced by który are normally separated with a comma.
So:
- powieści, której autora...
This is different from English, where that/which/who clauses are not always preceded by a comma. Polish uses the comma much more regularly in this kind of structure.
What is the most literal structure of the sentence?
A very literal breakdown is:
- W tej księgarni = in this bookshop
- szukam powieści = I am looking for a novel
- której autora = whose author / the author of which
- bardzo lubi = likes very much
- moja siostra = my sister
So the grammar is built like this:
- I am looking for [a novel]
- [whose author] my sister likes very much
That kind of nested structure is common in Polish and is worth getting used to.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PolishMaster Polish — from W tej księgarni szukam powieści, której autora bardzo lubi moja siostra to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions