Breakdown of Buku sejarah Melayu itu menarik.
Questions & Answers about Buku sejarah Melayu itu menarik.
Word-by-word:
- buku – book
- sejarah – history
- Melayu – Malay (Malay people / the Malay language / relating to the Malays)
- itu – that / the (a demonstrative pointing to something known or visible)
- menarik – interesting / attractive (literally from the root tarik, “to pull”)
So literally: book history Malay that interesting → “That Malay history book is interesting.”
Malay normally does not use a separate word for “is/are/am” when linking a noun to an adjective.
So:
- Buku sejarah Melayu itu menarik.
= The/That Malay history book *is interesting.*
The link “is” is understood from the structure [subject] + [adjective]. You only see words like ialah / adalah in more specific situations (often when linking to a noun phrase, not a simple adjective), e.g.:
- Buku itu ialah buku sejarah. – That book is a history book.
But with a simple adjective like menarik, you just place it after the subject, with no extra verb.
In normal, natural Malay, you do not say:
- ✗ Buku sejarah Melayu itu adalah menarik.
That sounds unnatural or overly influenced by English.
With predicate adjectives (like menarik, cantik, mahal), you simply say:
- Buku sejarah Melayu itu menarik.
You’ll see adalah or ialah mainly before nouns or more complex phrases, especially in formal writing:
- Masalah utama adalah kekurangan dana.
The main problem is the lack of funds.
itu is a demonstrative that literally means that (as opposed to ini = this).
However, in Malay it also works as a kind of definite marker, similar to the in English. Depending on context, buku sejarah Melayu itu can mean:
- that Malay history book (e.g. one we’re pointing at or have just mentioned), or
- the Malay history book (a specific one known to both speaker and listener).
So:
- Buku sejarah Melayu itu menarik.
Could be translated as either:
That Malay history book is interesting / The Malay history book is interesting.
In Malay, ini (this) and itu (that) usually come after the whole noun phrase, not before it.
Patterns:
- buku itu – that/the book
- buku sejarah itu – that/the history book
- buku sejarah Melayu itu – that/the Malay history book
So the structure is:
[buku] [sejarah] [Melayu] [itu]
head noun + modifiers + demonstrative
Putting itu at the end tells you “that particular one (that we know or see)”.
Itu buku sejarah Melayu menarik is not the normal, neutral way to say this sentence.
- Itu buku sejarah Melayu menarik.
Could be parsed as something like: “That, a Malay history book, is interesting” in a very odd, disjointed way, and sounds off to native speakers in standard Malay.
The natural way is:
- Buku sejarah Melayu itu menarik.
If you put itu at the start (Itu buku…), it usually functions as a pronoun meaning that (as a standalone subject), and you would then need a full clause after it, e.g.:
- Itu buku yang saya suka. – That is the book I like.
The overall structure is:
- Subject (noun phrase)
- Predicate (adjective)
Subject noun phrase:
- buku (book – head noun)
- sejarah (history – noun modifier)
- Melayu (Malay – adjective/noun used as adjective modifying sejarah)
- itu (that/the – demonstrative)
Predicate:
- menarik (interesting)
So:
[Buku sejarah Melayu itu] [menarik].
[That Malay history book] [is interesting].
Malay doesn’t strictly separate adjectives and stative verbs the way English does. menarik can function as:
A stative verb / adjective meaning “interesting / attractive”:
- Buku itu menarik. – The book is interesting.
An active verb meaning “to pull / to attract”:
- Dia menarik tali itu. – He/She pulled the rope.
- Iklan itu menarik perhatian saya. – The advertisement attracted my attention.
It comes from the root tarik (pull), with the prefix meN- → menarik.
In this sentence, it functions like an adjective (“interesting”).
By itself, buku is number-neutral. Buku sejarah Melayu itu menarik could mean:
- That Malay history book is interesting.
- Those Malay history books are interesting.
The number is usually clear from context. To make it explicit, Malay uses other words:
- buku itu – that book
- buku-buku itu – those books (reduplication shows plural)
- banyak buku sejarah Melayu itu – many of those Malay history books
- beberapa buku sejarah Melayu itu – several of those Malay history books
But in everyday speech, people often just say buku and let context show whether it’s one or more.
Melayu is capitalized because it is a proper name for:
- the Malay ethnic group, and
- the Malay language.
In buku sejarah Melayu:
- sejarah = history
- Melayu = Malay
So Melayu is modifying sejarah, giving:
- sejarah Melayu – Malay history (the history of the Malays / related to the Malay people/culture)
Then buku sejarah Melayu = book of Malay history / Malay history book.
Yes, sejarah Melayu corresponds well to Malay history.
Typical meanings:
- The history of the Malay people and their kingdoms.
- The school subject about that history.
- More generally, any historical topic related to the Malay world.
So buku sejarah Melayu is naturally understood as:
a book whose topic is Malay history, not just a book written in Malay.
If you wanted to emphasize the language of the book instead, you’d say:buku sejarah dalam bahasa Melayu – a history book in the Malay language.
You keep the same structure and modify menarik:
- Very interesting
- Buku sejarah Melayu itu sangat menarik.
- Buku sejarah Melayu itu amat menarik.
Both sangat and amat mean very.
- Not interesting
- Buku sejarah Melayu itu tidak menarik.
(tidak is the standard negator for adjectives and verbs.)
So the pattern is:
- [Subject] + [degree word] + [adjective]
- [Subject] + tidak + [adjective]
Yes. In colloquial Malay (especially in Malaysia), itu is often shortened to tu:
- Buku sejarah Melayu tu menarik.
This sounds more conversational and is very common in speech. The meaning is the same:
- itu → more standard/written
- tu → informal/spoken