Questions & Answers about Mana tahu seramik ini selamat di dalam tanur.
Literally, yes: mana often means which / where, and tahu means know. But mana tahu is a fixed expression in Malay.
Depending on context, it can mean things like:
- who knows
- maybe / perhaps
- you never know
- sometimes, with a different intonation, how would anyone know?
So learners should not translate it word-for-word as where know. In this sentence, it is best understood as an idiomatic expression, not a literal combination.
As written with a full stop, it looks like a statement.
That matters because mana tahu can be used in different ways:
- as a speculative opener: who knows / maybe
- as a rhetorical question: how would one know?
If you wanted a straightforward yes/no question such as Is this ceramic safe in a kiln?, Malay would more naturally use something like:
- Adakah seramik ini selamat di dalam tanur?
- Selamatkah seramik ini di dalam tanur?
So the punctuation and intonation are important here.