Jahitan itu rosak sejak saya membeli pakaian ini.

Questions & Answers about Jahitan itu rosak sejak saya membeli pakaian ini.

What does jahitan mean in this sentence?

Jahitan means stitching, seam, or the sewn part of a garment.

It comes from the root jahit, which means to sew.

So:

  • jahit = to sew
  • jahitan = stitching / seam / sewn work

In this sentence, jahitan itu most naturally means the stitching or that seam.

Why is itu placed after jahitan instead of before it?

In Malay, demonstratives such as ini (this) and itu (that/the) usually come after the noun, not before it.

So:

  • jahitan itu = that stitching / the stitching
  • pakaian ini = this clothing / this garment

This is one of the first word-order differences English speakers notice:

  • English: this garment
  • Malay: pakaian ini
Why do both itu and ini appear in the same sentence?

They are pointing to different things:

  • jahitan itu = that/the stitching
  • pakaian ini = this clothing / this garment

Malay allows ini and itu in the same sentence as long as they refer to different nouns or help show contrast.

Here, the speaker is talking about:

  1. a particular seam/stitching, and
  2. this item of clothing

So the sentence is not contradictory.

What part of speech is rosak here? Is it an adjective or a verb?

Rosak is often translated as damaged, broken, or spoiled. In this sentence, it functions like a predicate adjective or stative verb.

Malay often does not need a separate word for is.

So:

  • Jahitan itu rosak literally looks like the stitching damaged
  • but naturally it means The stitching is damaged

This is normal Malay sentence structure.

Why is there no word for is in the sentence?

Malay usually does not use a copula like English is/am/are in simple statements of description.

So:

  • Dia cantik = She is beautiful
  • Rumah itu besar = That house is big
  • Jahitan itu rosak = The stitching is damaged

English requires is, but Malay usually does not.

What does sejak mean here?

Sejak means since or ever since.

It introduces the starting point of a situation that continues afterward.

In this sentence:

  • sejak saya membeli pakaian ini = since I bought this garment

So the idea is that the stitching has been in a damaged state from the time of purchase onward.

Why is membeli used instead of just beli?

Membeli is the meN- form of beli (to buy). It is the more standard/formal active verb form.

So:

  • saya membeli pakaian ini = I bought this garment
  • saya beli pakaian ini = I bought this garment

Both are used, but they feel slightly different:

  • membeli = more formal, careful, written, standard
  • beli = more conversational, everyday speech

A native speaker might very naturally say:

  • Jahitan itu rosak sejak saya beli pakaian ini.
How does Malay show the meaning of English has been damaged since I bought it without a tense change?

Malay does not change the verb for tense the way English does.

Instead, Malay often relies on:

  • time words
  • context
  • aspect markers such as sudah
  • words like sejak

Here, sejak already tells you that the state started in the past and continues from that point.

So Jahitan itu rosak sejak saya membeli pakaian ini can naturally correspond to English:

  • The stitching has been damaged since I bought this garment
  • The stitching has been defective ever since I bought this garment

If you want to make the ongoing/resulting state even clearer, you could add sudah:

  • Jahitan itu sudah rosak sejak saya membeli pakaian ini.
Does pakaian ini mean one item of clothing or clothes in general?

Malay nouns usually do not mark singular/plural the way English does.

So pakaian can mean:

  • clothing
  • clothes
  • a garment
  • an item of clothing

The exact meaning depends on context.

In this sentence, because the speaker mentions a specific stitching problem, pakaian ini is most likely understood as:

  • this garment
  • this item of clothing

That is often more natural in English than these clothes here.

Is this sentence fully natural Malay?

Yes, it is understandable and grammatically acceptable, but a native speaker might choose a slightly more natural version depending on the situation.

Possible alternatives include:

  • Jahitan pakaian ini rosak sejak saya membelinya.
  • Jahitan pada pakaian ini rosak sejak saya membelinya.
  • Jahitan pakaian ini sudah rosak sejak saya beli lagi.
    (more colloquial, depending on region and context)

Why might someone rephrase it? Because jahitan itu sounds like the listener already knows which seam is being referred to, while pakaian ini introduces the garment itself. A speaker might prefer to connect them more directly.

Still, the original sentence is perfectly understandable.

Can itu sometimes mean the, not just that?

Yes. In many contexts, itu can function a bit like that, but in natural translation it is often better rendered as the when the noun is already identifiable.

So jahitan itu could be:

  • that stitching
  • the stitching

Which translation fits best depends on context.

English speakers often over-translate itu as that, but sometimes the sounds more natural.

How would this sentence sound in everyday spoken Malay?

A more casual spoken version could be:

Jahitan tu rosak sejak saya beli pakaian ni.

Changes:

  • itu → tu
  • ini → ni
  • membeli → beli

This is very common in conversation, while the original version sounds more standard or written.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
“What's the best way to learn Malay grammar?”
Malay grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Malay

Master Malay — from Jahitan itu rosak sejak saya membeli pakaian ini to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions