Breakdown of Mater rogat quantam aquam infans bibere velit.
Questions & Answers about Mater rogat quantam aquam infans bibere velit.
Why is velit in the subjunctive instead of vult?
Because quantam aquam infans bibere velit is an indirect question: Mother asks how much water the child wants to drink.
In Latin, indirect questions normally take the subjunctive. So after rogat (asks), Latin uses velit rather than the indicative vult.
- direct question: Quantam aquam vult infans bibere? = How much water does the child want to drink?
- indirect question: Mater rogat quantam aquam infans bibere velit. = Mother asks how much water the child wants to drink.
So velit is there because the clause is not being asked directly by the speaker; it is being reported after rogat.
Why is bibere an infinitive?
Bibere is the present active infinitive of bibo (to drink). It depends on velit:
- velit bibere = wants to drink
This works much like English:
- the child wants to drink water
Latin often uses volo + infinitive in exactly this way:
- vult dormire = he wants to sleep
- velit bibere = he wants to drink
So bibere is not the main verb of the sentence; it completes the meaning of velit.
Why is infans nominative, not accusative?
Because infans is the subject of velit (and logically also of bibere).
In the indirect question quantam aquam infans bibere velit, the child is the one who wants and the one who would drink, so infans stays in the nominative.
That is different from an accusative-and-infinitive construction, which Latin often uses after verbs like dicit (says) or putat (thinks). But here we do not have an indirect statement; we have an indirect question, so the subject remains nominative.
- Mater dicit infantem aquam bibere. = Mother says that the child is drinking water.
- Mater rogat quantam aquam infans bibere velit. = Mother asks how much water the child wants to drink.
Why are both quantam and aquam in the accusative?
Because aquam is the direct object of bibere, and quantam agrees with it.
- aquam = water (accusative singular)
- quantam = how much / what amount of (accusative feminine singular)
The adjective quantam must match aquam in:
- gender: feminine
- number: singular
- case: accusative
So:
- quantam aquam = how much water
Why is it quantam and not quantum?
Because quantam agrees with aquam, which is feminine singular accusative.
The basic dictionary form is quantus, quanta, quantum. Here the feminine accusative singular form is needed:
- masculine accusative singular: quantum
- feminine accusative singular: quantam
- neuter accusative singular: quantum
Since aqua is feminine, Latin uses quantam aquam, not quantum aquam.
What exactly is quantam aquam doing here? Is it just an object, or is it also the question word?
It does both jobs at once.
In the indirect question, quantam is the interrogative adjective that introduces the question idea: how much. At the same time, quantam aquam is also the direct object of bibere.
So in one phrase Latin expresses:
- the thing being asked about: how much
- the thing being drunk: water
That is why the clause can be understood as:
- how much water the child wants to drink
What is the main verb of the whole sentence?
The main verb is rogat.
Sentence structure:
- Mater = subject of the main clause
- rogat = main verb
- quantam aquam infans bibere velit = subordinate clause (an indirect question)
So the sentence is built like this:
- Mater rogat = Mother asks
- quantam aquam infans bibere velit = how much water the child wants to drink
Even though velit is a finite verb too, it belongs to the subordinate clause, not the main clause.
Could the word order be different?
Yes. Latin word order is fairly flexible because the endings show the grammatical roles.
This sentence could be rearranged in several ways without changing the basic meaning, for example:
- Mater quantam aquam infans bibere velit rogat.
- Quantam aquam infans bibere velit mater rogat.
- Infans quantam aquam bibere velit mater rogat.
However, the original order is quite natural:
- main clause first: Mater rogat
- then the indirect question: quantam aquam infans bibere velit
Latin word order often helps with emphasis or style, not just grammar.
Why is velit present subjunctive? Is this related to sequence of tenses?
Yes. After a main verb in a primary tense like rogat (present), Latin normally uses the present subjunctive in an indirect question when the action is viewed as present or future relative to the main verb.
So:
- rogat = she asks
- velit = wants / may want at the same time as the asking
If the main verb were in a past tense, Latin would often use the imperfect subjunctive instead:
- Mater rogabat quantam aquam infans bibere vellet.
- Mother was asking how much water the child wanted to drink.
So velit fits the normal sequence after a present main verb.
Who is understood as doing the drinking?
The one doing the drinking is infans.
Even though bibere is an infinitive and does not show person or number by itself, its subject is understood from the clause:
- infans bibere velit = the child wants to drink
So the child is both:
- the subject of velit
- the understood subject of bibere
Could Latin have said quantum aquae instead?
Latin can express how much water in more than one way, and learners may indeed meet other patterns. In this sentence, though, quantam aquam is a straightforward and perfectly understandable way to say how much water, with quantam agreeing directly with aquam.
So for this sentence, the important thing to notice is simply:
- quantam modifies aquam
- both are accusative because they function together as the object of bibere
If you later see different ways of expressing quantity, that is a broader style and usage question, not a problem with this sentence itself.
Is rogat here more like asks or asks someone?
Here rogat means simply asks in the sense of asks the question.
The sentence does not state whom the mother is asking; it only tells us what she asks:
- how much water the child wants to drink
If Latin wanted to specify the person being asked, it could add that separately. But in this sentence the focus is on the content of the question, not the person addressed.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Mater rogat quantam aquam infans bibere velit to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions