Breakdown of Philosophus dicit Alexandriam urbem doctam et claram esse.
Questions & Answers about Philosophus dicit Alexandriam urbem doctam et claram esse.
Why is Alexandriam in the accusative instead of Alexandria?
Because this sentence uses indirect statement after dicit (says).
In Latin, after verbs of saying, thinking, knowing, hearing, and similar verbs, the content of the statement is often expressed with:
- an accusative subject
- plus an infinitive verb
So instead of saying something like The philosopher says that Alexandria is..., Latin says, more literally:
- The philosopher says Alexandria to be...
That is why Alexandria becomes Alexandriam.
Why is esse used instead of est?
For the same reason: this is an indirect statement.
In a normal direct statement, you would say:
- Alexandria urbs docta et clara est
= Alexandria is a learned and famous city
But after dicit, Latin changes est to the infinitive esse:
- dicit Alexandriam ... esse
= he says that Alexandria is ...
So esse is the infinitive to be, and it is the standard verb form used in this construction.
Why is urbem also accusative?
Because urbem is in apposition to Alexandriam.
That means it is another noun describing the same thing:
- Alexandriam = Alexandria
- urbem = city
So Latin is saying:
- Alexandriam urbem = Alexandria, a city
Since Alexandriam is accusative in the indirect statement, urbem must match it in case. Both refer to the same thing, so both are accusative singular feminine.
Why are doctam and claram feminine accusative singular?
They agree with the noun they describe.
Here, doctam and claram describe urbem, and therefore also Alexandriam, since both nouns refer to the same city. Because urbem/Alexandriam is:
- feminine
- singular
- accusative
the adjectives must also be:
- feminine
- singular
- accusative
So we get:
- doctam
- claram
This is normal Latin adjective agreement.
What exactly is the role of urbem here? Is it necessary?
Urbem means city, and it helps characterize Alexandria more explicitly.
The phrase:
- Alexandriam urbem doctam et claram esse
means literally something like:
- Alexandria to be a learned and famous city
Without urbem, the sentence could still work:
- Philosophus dicit Alexandriam doctam et claram esse
That would mean:
- The philosopher says that Alexandria is learned and famous
But adding urbem makes the structure more concrete and often sounds more natural in Latin, because the adjectives doctam and claram are then attached to city.
How should I understand doctam when it describes a city? Can a city be learned?
Yes, but not in the sense that the city itself studies books.
When Latin describes a city as docta, it usually means something like:
- learned
- cultured
- scholarly
- intellectually distinguished
So urbem doctam suggests a city known for learning, education, literature, or intellectual life.
In smoother English, you might translate it as:
- a cultured and famous city
- a learned and renowned city
depending on context.
Why is there no Latin word for that in the philosopher says that Alexandria is...?
Because Latin usually does not need a separate word for that in this kind of sentence.
English commonly says:
- He says that Alexandria is...
Latin usually uses the accusative + infinitive construction instead:
- dicit Alexandriam ... esse
So the idea of that is built into the grammar, not expressed by a separate word.
What is the basic structure of the whole sentence?
The sentence breaks down like this:
- Philosophus = the philosopher
- dicit = says
- Alexandriam = Alexandria (accusative subject of the indirect statement)
- urbem = city (in apposition to Alexandriam)
- doctam et claram = learned and famous (adjectives agreeing with urbem/Alexandriam)
- esse = to be
So the structure is:
- main clause: Philosophus dicit
- indirect statement: Alexandriam urbem doctam et claram esse
More literally:
- The philosopher says Alexandria to be a learned and famous city
More naturally:
- The philosopher says that Alexandria is a learned and famous city
What tense is dicit, and how should I translate it?
Dicit is present tense, third person singular, from dicere.
It can mean:
- he says
- she says
- the philosopher says
- sometimes is saying, depending on context
In this sentence, the simplest translation is:
- The philosopher says...
Is the word order special here?
The word order is fairly natural for Latin, but Latin word order is much freer than English word order.
A few things to notice:
- Philosophus dicit puts the main clause first.
- The whole indirect statement follows it.
- Alexandriam urbem keeps the two linked nouns together.
- doctam et claram comes before esse, which is very common in Latin.
Latin could rearrange parts of this sentence without changing the basic meaning, as long as the forms still show the grammatical relationships.
So word endings, not position alone, tell you who is doing what.
What would the direct statement look like before it was turned into indirect statement?
The direct statement would be:
- Alexandria urbs docta et clara est.
That means:
- Alexandria is a learned and famous city.
When this becomes dependent on dicit, Latin changes it like this:
- Alexandria → Alexandriam
- urbs → urbem
- docta → doctam
- clara → claram
- est → esse
So the direct statement is converted into an accusative-and-infinitive construction.
Could Alexandriam urbem mean the city of Alexandria?
Not here.
If Latin wanted to say the city of Alexandria, it would normally use a different structure, often with a genitive or simply the proper name in apposition depending on context.
Here, Alexandriam and urbem are two accusative nouns referring to the same thing:
- Alexandria
- a city
So the sense is:
- Alexandria, a city
- or better in English, Alexandria is a city...
The sentence is not talking about one city belonging to Alexandria; it is identifying Alexandria as the city being described.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Philosophus dicit Alexandriam urbem doctam et claram esse to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions