Breakdown of Sub quercubus avia glandes numerat et dicit ex glandibus novam quercum nasci posse.
Questions & Answers about Sub quercubus avia glandes numerat et dicit ex glandibus novam quercum nasci posse.
Why is there no word for the or a in this sentence?
Why does sub take quercubus here, and what case is quercubus?
Here sub means under in the sense of location, so it takes the ablative case. Thus sub quercubus means under the oak trees or beneath the oaks.
A useful rule is:
- sub
- ablative = being under something
- sub
- accusative = motion to a place under something
So if someone were moving to a place under the trees, Latin could use the accusative instead.
Why is the form quercubus used instead of something like quercibus?
Quercubus is an ablative plural form of quercus, meaning oak or oak tree. This noun belongs to the fourth declension, and some fourth-declension nouns use -ubus in the dative/ablative plural.
So quercubus is a real and correct form, not a typo.
What is avia doing grammatically in the sentence?
Avia is the subject of both numerat and dicit. It is nominative singular feminine and means grandmother.
So the basic structure is:
- avia numerat = the grandmother counts
- avia dicit = the grandmother says
Latin often states the subject once and lets it apply to more than one verb.
What case is glandes, and why?
Glandes is accusative plural, the direct object of numerat. It answers the question what is the grandmother counting? She is counting acorns.
The dictionary form is glans, glandis, and the accusative plural is glandes.
Why is it ex glandibus?
The preposition ex means out of or from, and it takes the ablative case. So glandibus is ablative plural.
Thus:
- ex glandibus = from acorns / out of acorns
This phrase shows source or origin: the new oak comes from acorns.
What tense are numerat and dicit?
Both are present indicative active, third person singular:
- numerat = she counts
- dicit = she says
The subject is singular (avia), so the verbs are singular too.
How does dicit ex glandibus novam quercum nasci posse work? Where is the word for that?
After verbs of saying, thinking, knowing, and similar verbs, Latin often uses an accusative + infinitive construction instead of a clause with that.
So:
- dicit = she says
- novam quercum ... nasci posse = that a new oak can grow
Latin does not need a separate word for that here. The structure itself shows indirect statement.
A very literal unpacking would be something like:
- she says a new oak to be able to grow from acorns
But natural English is:
- she says that a new oak can grow from acorns
Why is novam quercum accusative, not nominative?
Because in this kind of indirect statement, the subject of the infinitive is put in the accusative case.
So in direct form, you might think of:
- nova quercus nascitur = a new oak grows / is born
But after dicit, Latin changes the subject into the accusative:
- dicit novam quercum nasci posse = she says that a new oak can grow
So novam quercum is the accusative singular of nova quercus.
What is nasci? Why does it look passive?
Nasci is the present infinitive of nascor. It is a deponent verb, which means it has passive-looking forms but an active meaning.
So although nasci looks passive, it means something active like:
- to be born
- to arise
- to spring up
- to grow
With plants and trees, nasci is very naturally understood as to grow or to spring up.
Why are there two infinitives, nasci posse?
Because posse means to be able, and it normally takes another infinitive to complete its meaning.
So:
- nasci = to grow
- posse = to be able
Together:
- nasci posse = to be able to grow
This is exactly like English can grow or to be able to grow.
Is the word order unusual?
By English standards, yes; by Latin standards, not really. Latin word order is much freer because the endings show each word’s role.
This sentence places important verbs and infinitives toward the end:
- numerat
- dicit
- nasci posse
That is very normal Latin style. The meaning depends mainly on case endings, not on rigid word order.
So even though English would normally say The grandmother counts acorns under the oaks and says that a new oak can grow from acorns, Latin can arrange the words more flexibly without becoming unclear.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Sub quercubus avia glandes numerat et dicit ex glandibus novam quercum nasci posse to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions