Breakdown of Cum pluvia gravis cadit, cives per portam in urbem intrant.
Questions & Answers about Cum pluvia gravis cadit, cives per portam in urbem intrant.
Why does cum mean when here? I thought cum could mean with.
Yes—cum has more than one use.
In this sentence, cum is a conjunction, introducing a clause:
- Cum pluvia gravis cadit = When heavy rain falls
But cum can also be a preposition meaning with, followed by the ablative:
- cum amico = with a friend
So the function depends on what follows:
- if cum introduces a verb and a whole clause, it often means when, since, or although
- if cum is followed by a noun in the ablative, it usually means with
Why is cadit singular, but intrant plural?
Because they have different subjects.
- pluvia = rain → singular
so cadit = falls - cives = citizens → plural
so intrant = enter
So:
- pluvia gravis cadit = heavy rain falls
- cives ... intrant = the citizens enter
Latin verbs change form to match their subjects in number (singular or plural).
Why is it pluvia gravis and not some other form of gravis?
Because gravis must agree with pluvia.
pluvia is:
- feminine
- singular
- nominative (the subject)
So the adjective gravis must also be:
- feminine
- singular
- nominative
That is why we get:
- pluvia gravis = heavy rain
This is a basic Latin rule: adjectives agree with the nouns they describe in gender, number, and case.
Why is cives nominative?
Because cives is the subject of intrant.
- cives = citizens
- intrant = enter
The people doing the action are the citizens, so cives is in the nominative case, which is the usual case for the subject of a sentence.
Its dictionary form is civis (citizen), and cives here is the nominative plural.
Why are portam and urbem in the accusative?
Because both are objects of prepositions that express motion.
- per portam = through the gate
- in urbem = into the city
Both per and in (when it means into) take the accusative.
So:
- porta becomes portam
- urbs becomes urbem
This is very common in Latin:
- per + accusative = through
- in + accusative = into, onto
- in + ablative = in, on (location, not motion)
What is the difference between per portam and in urbem?
They express two different ideas of movement.
- per portam = through the gate
This tells you the route or path. - in urbem = into the city
This tells you the destination.
So the sentence is not repeating the same idea twice. It means something like:
- the citizens go through the gate
- and thereby move into the city
Why is it in urbem and not in urbe?
Because in changes meaning depending on the case.
- in + accusative = into (motion toward)
- in + ablative = in or inside (location)
So:
- in urbem intrant = they enter into the city
- in urbe sunt = they are in the city
Here there is movement into the city, so the accusative urbem is correct.
Is the word order special? Why not put cives first?
Latin word order is more flexible than English word order because the endings show each word’s role.
This sentence begins with the cum clause:
- Cum pluvia gravis cadit = When heavy rain falls
Then comes the main clause:
- cives per portam in urbem intrant
Starting with the time clause is very natural in Latin, just as in English:
- When heavy rain falls, the citizens enter the city through the gate.
Could the order be changed? Yes, in many ways:
- Cives cum pluvia gravis cadit per portam in urbem intrant
- Cives in urbem per portam intrant
But the given order is clear and natural. Latin often uses word order for emphasis or style, not just grammar.
Why doesn’t Latin use words like the or a in this sentence?
Because Classical Latin has no articles.
So:
- pluvia can mean rain, the rain, or a rain
- cives can mean citizens or the citizens
- urbem can mean a city or the city
English has to choose an article when translating, but Latin usually leaves that to the context.
Why is cum followed by the indicative here, not the subjunctive?
Because this is a straightforward temporal clause: when heavy rain falls.
The verb in the cum clause is:
- cadit = present indicative
With cum, Latin can use different moods depending on meaning:
- indicative for a simple time sense: when
- subjunctive in many clauses meaning since, although, or in more literary narrative uses
Here the sentence is simple and factual, so the indicative is expected.
What are the basic dictionary forms of the words in this sentence?
Here they are:
- cum = when / with
- pluvia, pluviae = rain
- gravis, grave = heavy, serious
- cado, cadere, cecidi = fall
- civis, civis = citizen
- per = through
- porta, portae = gate
- in = into / in
- urbs, urbis = city
- intro, intrare = enter
And the forms used here are:
- pluvia = nominative singular
- gravis = nominative singular agreeing with pluvia
- cadit = 3rd person singular present
- cives = nominative plural
- portam = accusative singular
- urbem = accusative singular
- intrant = 3rd person plural present
Could gravis mean something other than heavy?
Yes. gravis has a range of meanings depending on context, including:
- heavy
- serious
- weighty
- sometimes severe
With pluvia, the natural meaning is heavy:
- pluvia gravis = heavy rain
So context helps decide which English word is best.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Cum pluvia gravis cadit, cives per portam in urbem intrant to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions