Breakdown of Nauta dicit Corinthum quoque urbem claram esse et multos mercatores ibi manere.
Questions & Answers about Nauta dicit Corinthum quoque urbem claram esse et multos mercatores ibi manere.
Where is the word that after dicit?
Latin often does not use a separate word for that after verbs like dicit.
Instead, it uses an accusative + infinitive construction, often called an indirect statement:
- Corinthum ... esse
- multos mercatores ... manere
So after Nauta dicit, Latin literally gives something like:
- the sailor says Corinth to be a famous city
- and many merchants to stay there
In natural English, we turn that into the sailor says that Corinth is also a famous city and that many merchants stay there.
Why is Corinthum in the accusative?
Because Corinthum is the subject of an infinitive inside an indirect statement.
In English, the subject of is would be nominative: Corinth is famous.
But in Latin, after dicit, the subject of the reported statement goes into the accusative:
- direct idea: Corinthus est urbs clara
- reported after dicit: Corinthum urbem claram esse
So Corinthum is not the direct object in the ordinary English sense; it is the accusative subject of esse.
Why are urbem and claram accusative too?
They are accusative because they go with Corinthum inside the indirect statement.
- urbem means city
- claram means famous or well-known
Here urbem claram tells us what Corinth is: a famous city. Because Corinthum is accusative, the noun and adjective that describe it are also put in the accusative:
- Corinthum = the accusative subject
- urbem = predicate noun in the accusative
- claram = adjective agreeing with urbem
So the whole phrase works as Corinth to be a famous city, which English naturally turns into that Corinth is a famous city.
Why do we get esse and manere instead of est and manent?
Because after dicit, Latin uses infinitives in indirect statement.
So:
- esse = to be
- manere = to remain / stay / live
Latin says:
- Corinthum ... esse
- multos mercatores ibi manere
English usually changes those infinitives into normal finite verbs:
- that Corinth is ...
- that many merchants stay ...
So the infinitives are not strange extra verbs; they are the normal Latin way to report what someone says, thinks, hears, knows, and so on.
Is multos mercatores the object of dicit or the subject of manere?
It is the subject of manere inside the second indirect statement.
That second part is:
- multos mercatores ibi manere
This means literally many merchants to stay there.
So:
- multos mercatores = accusative subject
- manere = infinitive verb
- ibi = there
A useful detail: mercatores by itself could be nominative plural or accusative plural, since third-declension masculine nouns have -es in both forms. But multos shows clearly that the whole phrase is accusative.
What does quoque mean, and why is it placed after Corinthum?
Quoque means also or too.
It usually comes after the word it emphasizes. So:
- Corinthum quoque = Corinth too / Corinth also
That placement suggests that Corinth is being added to something already mentioned. In other words, the sailor is saying that Corinth, along with some other place or places already under discussion, is a famous city.
What does ibi refer to?
Ibi means there.
In this sentence, it refers to Corinth. So multos mercatores ibi manere means that many merchants stay or live there, that is, in Corinth.
Latin often uses ibi instead of repeating the place name.
Why is nauta first declension if it means sailor?
Because not all first-declension nouns are feminine.
Nauta is one of several first-declension nouns referring to people, especially occupations, that are masculine or common in gender. So even though it ends in -a, it can mean a male sailor.
This is something English speakers often notice early, because they learn that first declension is usually feminine, but not always.
What exactly is et connecting here?
Et connects two parts that both depend on dicit.
The structure is:
- Nauta dicit
- Corinthum quoque urbem claram esse
- et
- multos mercatores ibi manere
So the sailor says two things:
- that Corinth is also a famous city
- that many merchants stay there
Both are indirect statements, and et joins them.
How should I break this sentence up to understand the word order?
A good way is to separate the main clause from the reported statement.
Main clause:
- Nauta dicit = the sailor says
Then the reported content:
- Corinthum quoque urbem claram esse
- et multos mercatores ibi manere
Latin word order is more flexible than English word order, so you do not need to read it strictly left to right the way you would in English. The endings tell you how the words fit together:
- Corinthum / urbem / claram belong together
- multos mercatores belongs with manere
- ibi goes with manere
- quoque adds emphasis to Corinthum
So it helps to read by groups rather than by individual words.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Nauta dicit Corinthum quoque urbem claram esse et multos mercatores ibi manere to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions