Breakdown of Cum consul decretum senatui recitaret, quidam cives suffragium statim ferri volebant.
Questions & Answers about Cum consul decretum senatui recitaret, quidam cives suffragium statim ferri volebant.
Why does cum mean when/while here, and not with?
Latin cum has more than one use.
- As a preposition with the ablative, it means with:
cum amico = with a friend - As a conjunction introducing a clause, it can mean when, while, since, or although, depending on context.
Here cum introduces a whole clause:
Cum consul decretum senatui recitaret ...
So it is the conjunction, not the preposition. In this sentence it gives background time/circumstance: when or while the consul was reading the decree to the senate.
Why is recitaret in the subjunctive?
Because this is a cum clause in past narrative.
In Latin, when cum introduces background circumstances in a past-time sentence, the verb is very often put in the subjunctive. This is commonly called a circumstantial cum clause.
So:
- cum ... recitaret = when/while ... was reading
It is not mainly showing doubt or unreality here. The subjunctive is used because of the kind of clause it is.
Why is recitaret imperfect subjunctive, not perfect or present?
The imperfect subjunctive fits the time relationship in the sentence.
Both parts describe actions in the past that were going on at the same time:
- recitaret = was reading / was reciting
- volebant = were wanting
So the sense is:
- while the consul was in the middle of reading...
- some citizens wanted...
The imperfect gives a continuous/background feel, which matches the scene well.
What case is consul, and what is its job in the sentence?
consul is nominative singular.
It is the subject of recitaret:
- consul recitaret = the consul was reading
So the consul is the person doing the action in the cum clause.
What case is decretum, and how do we know what it does?
decretum is accusative singular neuter.
It is the direct object of recitaret:
- recitare decretum = to read/recite a decree
So:
- consul decretum recitaret = the consul was reading the decree
Why is senatui dative?
senatui is dative singular of senatus.
It is an indirect object, answering to whom?
- recitare aliquid alicui = to read something to someone
So:
- decretum senatui recitaret = was reading the decree to the senate
A native English speaker may want to make it possessive, like the senate’s decree, but that is not what the Latin form shows here. The dative says the senate is the audience/recipient, not the possessor.
What does quidam mean here?
quidam means a certain or some.
Here it modifies cives:
- quidam cives = some citizens / certain citizens
It often suggests an indefinite but real group—not everybody, just some particular people.
Why is cives nominative plural?
Because cives is the subject of volebant.
- cives volebant = the citizens wanted
It is plural because the verb is plural:
- volebant = they were wanting / wanted
So quidam cives is the subject of the main clause.
Why is volebant imperfect?
The imperfect shows an action or state that was ongoing in the past.
So volebant is not just a simple one-time wanted. It has the sense:
- were wanting
- wanted at that moment
- were eager for
This fits the scene: while the consul was still reading, some citizens were already wanting the vote to happen immediately.
Why is it ferri, not ferre?
ferri is the present passive infinitive of ferre.
- ferre = to carry, bear, bring
- ferri = to be carried / to be brought
In political language, expressions with suffragium and ferre are connected with voting. Here the passive infinitive gives the idea:
- suffragium ferri = for the vote to be taken / for voting to be carried out
So the citizens were not wanting to carry the vote themselves in the grammar of the sentence; they wanted the vote to be taken.
How does suffragium ferri volebant work grammatically?
This is a verb of wanting plus an infinitive construction.
- volebant = they wanted
- ferri = to be taken
- suffragium is the thing connected with that infinitive: the vote
So the whole idea is:
- they wanted the vote to be taken immediately
Latin often uses an infinitive after volo to express what someone wants to happen.
Why is suffragium singular, not plural?
In Latin, suffragium can mean:
- a vote
- voting
- the vote as a procedure or decision
So the singular here can refer to the act of taking a vote in a general or collective sense:
- suffragium statim ferri = for the vote to be taken at once
English often uses the vote similarly.
What is statim modifying?
statim means immediately / at once.
It modifies the verbal idea ferri:
- statim ferri = to be taken immediately
So it tells us when they wanted the vote to happen.
How important is the word order in this sentence?
Latin word order is more flexible than English word order because the endings show the grammar. But the order still helps with emphasis and flow.
Here the order is very natural:
- Cum consul decretum senatui recitaret
first gives the background situation - quidam cives
then introduces the people reacting - suffragium statim ferri
puts the desired action before the verb of wanting - volebant
ends the sentence with the main verb
So the structure is roughly:
- background scene
- main actors
- what they wanted
- the wanting itself
Could cum here be translated as both when and while?
Yes.
Because the imperfect gives an ongoing background action, both are possible depending on how you want the English to sound:
- When the consul was reading the decree to the senate...
- While the consul was reading the decree to the senate...
While often brings out the continuing action a little more clearly, but when is also perfectly reasonable.
Is this sentence showing a contrast between the consul and the citizens?
Yes, that is a natural way to read it.
The cum clause sets up the official process:
- the consul was reading the decree to the senate
The main clause shows that some citizens wanted to move faster:
- they wanted the vote taken immediately
So the sentence suggests impatience or urgency on the part of quidam cives. Even if the meaning has already been given to the learner, this is a useful thing to notice in the grammar and structure.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Cum consul decretum senatui recitaret, quidam cives suffragium statim ferri volebant to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions