Breakdown of Fratrem stultitiae suae nondum pudet, sed postea sororem rogabit ut sibi ignoscat.
Questions & Answers about Fratrem stultitiae suae nondum pudet, sed postea sororem rogabit ut sibi ignoscat.
Why is fratrem accusative instead of nominative?
Because pudet is an impersonal verb. With pudet, Latin does not put the person who feels shame in the nominative. Instead:
- the person ashamed goes in the accusative
- the thing they are ashamed of goes in the genitive
So fratrem stultitiae suae pudet literally works like it shames the brother of his own foolishness, which English turns into the brother is ashamed of his own foolishness.
Why is stultitiae suae genitive?
Because pudet normally takes the genitive of the cause or reason for the shame. Here, stultitiae tells you what the shame is about.
So:
- fratrem = the person feeling shame
- stultitiae suae = the thing causing the shame
This is a standard pattern with pudet.
Why is it suae and not eius?
suae is the reflexive possessive adjective, and it refers back to the same person involved in the clause: here, fratrem.
So stultitiae suae means of his own foolishness.
Latin uses suus, sua, suum when something belongs to or refers back to the subject or central person of the clause. Even though fratrem is accusative here, it is still the person whose foolishness is meant, so suae is the natural choice.
If Latin used eius, that would usually point to someone else’s foolishness.
Is there an understood subject for rogabit?
Yes. Latin often leaves subject pronouns unstated because the verb ending already shows the person and number.
- rogabit = he/she will ask
From the context, the understood subject is the same person as fratrem in the first clause. So the sentence continues talking about the brother.
Why is sororem accusative?
Because it is the direct object of rogabit.
The pattern is:
- rogare aliquem = to ask someone
- ut + subjunctive = what you ask them to do
So:
- sororem rogabit = he will ask his sister
- ut sibi ignoscat = to forgive him
Why is there no suam with sororem?
Latin often omits possessive adjectives when the relationship is already clear from context, especially with:
- family members
- body parts
- obvious personal belongings
So sororem can naturally mean his sister here even without suam. English often has to make that relationship explicit, but Latin does not always need to.
Why does Latin use ut after rogabit?
After verbs of asking, urging, ordering, persuading, and similar ideas, Latin commonly uses ut + subjunctive to express the requested action.
So rogabit ut ignoscat literally means he will ask that she forgive, which English usually renders more naturally as he will ask her to forgive.
This is often called an indirect command or a substantive clause after a verb of asking.
Why is ignoscat subjunctive, and why is it present subjunctive?
It is subjunctive because it comes after ut with a verb of asking: rogabit ut ...
It is present subjunctive because of sequence of tenses:
- rogabit is a primary tense because it is future
- after a primary tense, Latin normally uses the present subjunctive for an action that is simultaneous with or later than the main verb
So rogabit ut ignoscat is exactly what you would expect: he will ask that she forgive.
English does not show this the same way, so we usually just say he will ask her to forgive.
Why is sibi dative, and who does it refer to?
It is dative because ignoscere takes the dative of the person forgiven:
- alicui ignoscere = to forgive someone
So sibi ignoscat means may/should forgive him/her/themself, depending on context.
Here, sibi is a reflexive pronoun, and in a dependent clause like this it normally refers back to the subject of the main verb, not to the understood subject of ignoscat. So the meaning is:
- he will ask his sister to forgive him
not:
- he will ask his sister to forgive herself
What do nondum and postea contribute?
They create a clear time contrast:
- nondum = not yet
- postea = afterwards / later
So the sentence sets up a progression:
- first, he is not yet ashamed
- later, he will ask for forgiveness
These two adverbs help show the change over time.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Fratrem stultitiae suae nondum pudet, sed postea sororem rogabit ut sibi ignoscat to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions