Breakdown of Hoc scamnum sella vetere commodius est, itaque duae discipulae ibi libenter sedent.
Questions & Answers about Hoc scamnum sella vetere commodius est, itaque duae discipulae ibi libenter sedent.
Why is hoc used here?
Hoc is the nominative neuter singular form of hic, haec, hoc meaning this.
It is used because it goes with scamnum, which is a neuter singular noun. Since hoc scamnum is the subject of est, the nominative case is needed.
So:
- hoc = this
- scamnum = a neuter singular noun
- therefore hoc scamnum = this bench/stool
What is the difference between scamnum and sella?
They are two different kinds of seat.
- scamnum usually means something like a bench, stool, or seat without a back
- sella usually means a chair
So the sentence is comparing this bench/stool with an old chair, not using two different Latin words for the same exact object.
Why does commodius end in -ius?
Commodius is the neuter singular nominative form of the comparative adjective commodior, commodius.
It agrees with scamnum, which is neuter singular. Since the sentence says that this bench is more comfortable / more convenient, the comparative adjective must match scamnum.
So:
- masculine/feminine comparative: commodior
- neuter comparative: commodius
Because scamnum is neuter, Latin uses commodius.
Why is it sella vetere and not sella vetus?
Because sella vetere is in the ablative singular.
After a comparative like commodius, Latin can put the thing compared in the ablative instead of using a separate word for than. This is called the ablative of comparison.
So:
- sella becomes ablative singular sella
- vetus changes to ablative singular vetere
That is why Latin says sella vetere = than an old chair.
Why is there no separate word for than?
Latin has two common ways to make a comparison.
Use quam:
- Hoc scamnum commodius est quam sella vetus.
Use the ablative of comparison:
- Hoc scamnum sella vetere commodius est.
This sentence uses the second pattern. So sella vetere by itself already means than an old chair.
What does itaque mean here?
Itaque means and so, therefore, or so.
It introduces the result of the first clause:
- the bench is more comfortable,
- therefore the two students like to sit there.
So it connects the two ideas logically.
Why is it duae discipulae and not duo discipulae?
Because discipulae is feminine, and the numeral two must agree with it.
Latin has different forms for two:
- masculine: duo
- feminine: duae
- neuter: duo
Since discipula means female student, the plural discipulae is feminine, so the correct form is duae.
What kind of word is ibi?
Ibi is an adverb meaning there or in that place.
It does not change its form for case, number, or gender. It simply tells you where the action happens.
Here it means the two students sit there, that is, on that bench / in that place.
What does libenter add to the sentence?
Libenter is an adverb meaning gladly, willingly, or with pleasure.
It modifies sedent and tells you how they sit there:
- not just they sit there
- but they gladly sit there
So it adds the idea that they do this happily or with enjoyment.
What form is sedent?
Sedent is the third person plural present active indicative of sedeo, sedere, meaning to sit.
So sedent means:
- they sit
- or in smoother English, sometimes they are sitting
It is plural because the subject is duae discipulae.
Why does the sentence use est in the first clause and sedent in the second?
Because the two clauses have different subjects.
First clause:
- Hoc scamnum ... commodius est
- subject: hoc scamnum = singular
- so the verb is est = is
Second clause:
- duae discipulae ibi libenter sedent
- subject: duae discipulae = plural
- so the verb is sedent = sit
Each clause has its own subject-verb agreement.
Why is the word order different from normal English word order?
Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order because the endings show how the words function.
English usually depends heavily on order:
- subject + verb + object/complement
Latin can move words around more freely for emphasis or style. In this sentence:
- Hoc scamnum comes first to set the topic
- sella vetere is placed near commodius to complete the comparison
- ibi libenter comes before sedent to emphasize where and how the students sit
So the word order may feel unusual to an English speaker, but the endings make the grammar clear.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Hoc scamnum sella vetere commodius est, itaque duae discipulae ibi libenter sedent to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions