Breakdown of Bonum discipulum magistris parere decet.
Questions & Answers about Bonum discipulum magistris parere decet.
Why is discipulum in the accusative?
Because decet commonly takes the person concerned in the accusative.
So:
- bonum discipulum = a good student in the accusative
- decet = it is fitting / it is proper
The idea is not quite the good student does something, but rather it is proper for a good student to do something.
So the structure is:
- bonum discipulum ... decet = it befits a good student ...
Why is it bonum discipulum, not bonus discipulus?
Because the adjective has to agree with the noun in gender, number, and case.
Here:
- discipulum is masculine singular accusative
- so bonum must also be masculine singular accusative
That is why you get:
- bonus discipulus = a good student as a nominative subject
- bonum discipulum = a good student in the accusative
Why is parere an infinitive?
Because after decet, Latin often uses an infinitive to say what it is proper to do.
So:
- parere = to obey
- bonum discipulum magistris parere decet = it is proper for a good student to obey teachers
The infinitive phrase magistris parere functions like to obey teachers in English.
Why is magistris dative and not accusative?
Because pareo, parere takes the dative case, not the accusative.
So Latin says:
- magistris parere = literally to obey to the teachers or to be obedient to the teachers
But in normal English we simply say:
- to obey the teachers
This is very common in Latin: some verbs that take a direct object in English instead take the dative in Latin.
What exactly does decet mean here?
Decet comes from decere, meaning:
- to be fitting
- to be proper
- to be suitable
- to be becoming
So bonum discipulum magistris parere decet can be understood as:
- It is proper for a good student to obey teachers
- It befits a good student to obey teachers
Befits is closer to the Latin, though it is proper is more natural for many learners.
Is there a hidden it in the sentence?
In English, we usually say:
- It is proper for a good student to obey teachers
Latin does not need a separate word for that it.
The verb decet by itself can express the idea. The infinitive phrase magistris parere supplies the content of what is fitting.
So English uses a dummy subject it, but Latin does not have to.
Why is there no word for a or the?
Because Latin has no articles.
So discipulum can mean, depending on context:
- a student
- the student
- sometimes just student
Here, English naturally translates the sense as:
- a good student
But Latin does not need a separate word for a.
What is the basic word order here, and why is decet at the end?
Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order because the endings show the grammatical relationships.
This sentence is arranged as:
- Bonum discipulum = a good student
- magistris parere = to obey teachers
- decet = it is proper
A very literal English rendering would be:
- A good student to obey teachers is fitting
That sounds unnatural in English, so we translate more naturally:
- It is proper for a good student to obey teachers
Putting decet at the end is completely normal Latin style.
Could the sentence be written in a different order?
Yes. For example, Latin could also say:
- Bonum discipulum decet magistris parere
- Magistris parere bonum discipulum decet
The core meaning would stay the same, because the endings still show the roles:
- bonum discipulum = accusative
- magistris = dative
- parere = infinitive
- decet = verb
Different word orders mainly change emphasis or style, not the basic meaning.
Could magistris be ablative instead of dative?
The form magistris could, by itself, be either dative plural or ablative plural.
But in this sentence it must be dative, because parere takes the dative.
So here:
- magistris = to/for the teachers grammatically
- in idiomatic English: the teachers
This is a good example of how you often identify a case not just from the ending, but from the verb it goes with.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Bonum discipulum magistris parere decet to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions