Breakdown of Medicus dicit puerum morbo gravi non laborare.
Questions & Answers about Medicus dicit puerum morbo gravi non laborare.
Why is puerum in the accusative instead of the nominative?
Because after dicit (says), Latin often uses an indirect statement construction.
In English, we say:
- The doctor says that the boy is not suffering...
In Latin, instead of using that plus a normal finite verb, Latin commonly uses:
- accusative noun + infinitive
So:
- puerum = the boy as the subject of the infinitive
- laborare = to be suffering / to suffer
That is why puerum is accusative, not nominative.
Why is laborare an infinitive instead of a normal verb like laborat?
For the same reason: this is an indirect statement.
After verbs of saying, thinking, knowing, perceiving, and similar verbs, Latin often uses:
- subject in the accusative
- verb in the infinitive
So instead of something like:
- Medicus dicit quod puer non laborat
Latin much more naturally says: - Medicus dicit puerum non laborare
So laborare is not the main verb of the sentence. The main verb is dicit.
The infinitive laborare is part of what the doctor says.
Is this an example of the accusative-and-infinitive construction?
Yes. This is a classic accusative-and-infinitive indirect statement.
The structure is:
- Medicus dicit = The doctor says
- puerum ... non laborare = that the boy is not suffering...
More literally:
- The doctor says the boy not to be suffering...
That literal English sounds awkward, but it helps show how Latin is built.
So:
- puerum = accusative subject of the infinitive
- laborare = infinitive verb
This is one of the most important Latin sentence patterns to learn.
Why is morbo gravi in the ablative?
Because laborare can take the ablative to express what someone is suffering from, troubled by, or afflicted with.
So:
- morbo = from/with a disease
- gravi = serious, severe, agreeing with morbo
Together:
- morbo gravi = from a serious illness / with a serious disease
This is a standard Latin idiom:
- morbo laborare = to suffer from an illness
So the ablative here is not random; it is the case regularly used with this expression.
What does non negate here?
Non negates laborare.
So the idea is:
- puerum morbo gravi non laborare = that the boy is not suffering from a serious illness
It does not mean:
- the doctor is not speaking
- the illness is not serious
It specifically denies the action/state expressed by laborare.
Because non stands right before the infinitive, it is very clear that the negation belongs to that infinitive clause.
What is the grammatical role of each word in the sentence?
Here is a breakdown:
Medicus — nominative singular
doctor; the subject of dicitdicit — 3rd person singular, present active indicative of dicere
sayspuerum — accusative singular of puer
boy; the subject of the infinitive in indirect statementmorbo — ablative singular of morbus
disease/illness; used with laboraregravi — ablative singular of gravis
serious/severe; agrees with morbonon — adverb
notlaborare — present active infinitive of laborare
to suffer / to be afflicted / to be troubled
Why does gravi end the same way as morbo?
Because gravi is an adjective describing morbo, and Latin adjectives must agree with the nouns they modify in:
- case
- number
- gender
Here:
- morbo is masculine, singular, ablative
- gravi is also masculine, singular, ablative
So they match:
- morbo gravi = with/from a serious illness
Even though the endings are different from what you may expect from first/second-declension adjectives, gravis is a third-declension adjective, so its ablative singular form is gravi.
What is the basic word order here, and could it be different?
The sentence is perfectly normal Latin word order, but Latin is much freer with word order than English because the endings show the grammar.
Current order:
- Medicus dicit puerum morbo gravi non laborare
A more grouped way to understand it is:
- Medicus dicit / puerum morbo gravi non laborare
Latin could also rearrange parts for emphasis, for example:
- Medicus puerum non laborare morbo gravi dicit
- Puerum medicus morbo gravi non laborare dicit
The meaning would stay basically the same, though the emphasis might shift.
So word order helps style and emphasis, but the case endings do most of the grammatical work.
Does laborare literally mean to work here?
Not here.
You may know laborare from the idea of labor or work, and in some contexts it can mean to toil or to work hard. But with morbo or other expressions of trouble, it means:
- to suffer
- to be afflicted
- to be troubled
So:
- morbo laborare = to suffer from an illness
This is a very common shift in meaning with Latin verbs: the exact translation depends on the words used with them.
Could Latin have used quod for that instead of the accusative-and-infinitive?
Sometimes later Latin, and occasionally even earlier Latin in some contexts, can use quod-clauses. But in standard classical Latin, after a verb like dicit, the normal construction for indirect statement is the accusative-and-infinitive.
So classical Latin strongly prefers:
- Medicus dicit puerum morbo gravi non laborare
rather than:
- Medicus dicit quod puer morbo gravi non laborat
A learner should definitely treat the accusative-and-infinitive version as the standard pattern.
How would this sentence look if it were a direct statement instead of indirect statement?
The direct statement would be:
- Puer morbo gravi non laborat.
The boy is not suffering from a serious illness.
Then, to make it indirect after Medicus dicit:
- puer becomes puerum
- laborat becomes laborare
So:
- Puer morbo gravi non laborat
becomes - Medicus dicit puerum morbo gravi non laborare
That transformation is a very useful way to understand Latin indirect statement.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Medicus dicit puerum morbo gravi non laborare to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions