Breakdown of Fama bona discipulae omnibus grata est.
Questions & Answers about Fama bona discipulae omnibus grata est.
What is the subject of the sentence?
The subject is fama bona discipulae as a noun phrase, with fama as the main noun.
- fama = reputation / report
- bona = good, agreeing with fama
- discipulae = of the female student in the shown meaning
A good way to see this is that the verb is est, singular, and the predicate adjective is grata, also singular. Both point to a singular subject centered on fama.
Why is grata feminine singular?
Because grata agrees with fama, which is feminine singular.
In this sentence, grata est means is pleasing / is welcome / is dear. Even though grata is separated from fama, it still matches it in:
- gender: feminine
- number: singular
- case: nominative
So Latin is saying that the reputation is pleasing, not that the student is pleasing.
What case is discipulae here?
Here, discipulae is genitive singular, meaning of the female student.
So the phrase is understood as the female student's good reputation.
This is a very common point of confusion, because discipulae can have several possible forms:
- genitive singular: of the female student
- dative singular: to/for the female student
- nominative plural: the female students
- vocative plural
The meaning and the sentence structure show that genitive singular is the right choice here.
How do I know bona goes with fama, not with discipulae?
Because bona matches fama in form.
- fama is nominative feminine singular
- bona is nominative feminine singular
But discipulae here is genitive singular, so bona cannot be modifying it.
Latin adjectives must agree with the nouns they modify in gender, number, and case, so the matching endings are a big clue.
Why is omnibus dative?
Because gratus, -a, -um with esse regularly takes the dative of the person affected.
So:
- grata est omnibus = is pleasing to everyone / is welcome to everyone
This is one of those places where Latin works differently from English. English often says everyone likes it, but Latin often says it is pleasing to everyone.
What exactly does grata est mean?
Literally, grata est means is pleasing, is welcome, or is dear.
The adjective gratus, -a, -um often describes how something is received by someone. With a dative, it means something like:
- pleasing to
- welcome to
- dear to
So omnibus grata est means is pleasing to everyone or is welcome to everyone.
Does fama really mean fame here?
Not necessarily in the modern English sense of celebrity.
Latin fama can mean things like:
- report
- reputation
- rumor
- public talk
In this sentence, it most naturally means reputation. So fama bona is a good reputation, not necessarily fame in the sense of being famous.
Why is the word order different from English?
Because Latin word order is much freer than English word order.
English relies heavily on word order to show who is doing what. Latin relies much more on endings. That means Latin can move words around for emphasis, rhythm, or style.
So in this sentence:
- fama comes first for prominence
- est comes at the end, which is very common in Latin
- discipulae can come after fama bona even though in English we would usually say the student's good reputation
The endings, not the position, tell you how the words fit together.
Could the sentence be written as Bona fama discipulae omnibus grata est?
Yes. That would still mean the same thing.
Both fama bona and bona fama can mean good reputation. In many simple sentences, changing the order of an adjective and noun does not change the basic meaning.
Latin writers may choose one order or another for:
- emphasis
- style
- rhythm
So this is mostly a word-order variation, not a grammar change.
Could discipulae mean something different in another sentence?
Yes. Discipulae is an ambiguous form by itself.
Depending on context, it could mean:
- of the female student — genitive singular
- to/for the female student — dative singular
- the female students — nominative plural
- O female students! — vocative plural
That is why context matters so much in Latin. You do not identify the form from the ending alone; you identify it from the ending plus the sentence structure and meaning.
Why is omnibus not the subject?
Because omnibus is dative plural here, not nominative.
The subject has to fit with the singular est and grata, and that role is filled by fama. Also, the construction grata est omnibus naturally means is pleasing to everyone, where omnibus is the person receiving the feeling.
So:
- fama = subject
- omnibus = dative of the people to whom it is pleasing
Is there anything specifically feminine about discipulae?
Yes. Discipula means female student. It is the feminine form.
- discipula = female student
- discipulus = male student
So discipulae here means of the female student, not just a gender-neutral student in strict Latin grammar.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Fama bona discipulae omnibus grata est to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions