Breakdown of Libertas grata est, sed salus quoque servanda est.
Questions & Answers about Libertas grata est, sed salus quoque servanda est.
What case are libertas and salus?
Both are nominative singular. They are the subjects of their clauses:
- Libertas grata est = Freedom is welcome / pleasing
- salus quoque servanda est = safety too must be preserved
Both nouns are feminine, third-declension nouns.
Why is it grata est and not gratus est or gratum est?
Because grata agrees with libertas.
In Latin, adjectives must agree with the noun they describe in:
- gender
- number
- case
Libertas is feminine singular nominative, so the adjective must also be feminine singular nominative: grata.
Does grata est mean is grateful?
No. Here grata means something like welcome, pleasing, or dear.
That can confuse English speakers because gratus, grata, gratum is related to the idea of pleasing or thankful, but in a sentence like this:
- Libertas grata est
the meaning is Freedom is welcome / dear / pleasing, not Freedom is grateful.
What exactly does quoque mean here?
Quoque means also or too.
It usually comes after the word it emphasizes. So:
- salus quoque = safety too / safety also
That is why the Latin does not put it before salus. English often says also safety or safety too, but Latin commonly places quoque after the emphasized word.
What is servanda est? Why isn’t it just a normal passive verb?
Servanda est is a very common Latin construction called the passive periphrastic.
It is made from:
- a gerundive: servanda
- a form of esse: est
So:
- servanda est = must be preserved / is to be preserved
The gerundive adds the idea of necessity or obligation, not just simple passive action.
Compare:
- servatur = is being preserved / is preserved
- servanda est = must be preserved
Why is it servanda?
Because servanda agrees with salus.
The base verb is servo, servare = to preserve, save, protect.
Its gerundive is:
- servandus masculine
- servanda feminine
- servandum neuter
Since salus is feminine singular nominative, the form must be servanda.
So:
- salus servanda est = safety must be preserved
Why is est used twice?
Because each half of the sentence has its own predicate:
- Libertas grata est
- sed salus quoque servanda est
In the first clause, est is a normal linking verb:
- libertas
- grata
- est
- grata
In the second, est helps form the passive periphrastic:
- salus
- servanda
- est
- servanda
Latin can sometimes omit est, but here repeating it makes the structure clear and balanced.
What kind of word is sed?
Sed is a conjunction meaning but.
It connects the two ideas:
- Freedom is welcome
- but safety also must be preserved
So the sentence sets up a contrast or balancing statement: freedom is valuable, but safety matters too.
Are libertas and salus both third-declension nouns?
Yes.
- libertas, libertatis = freedom, liberty
- salus, salutis = safety, welfare, well-being
Both are feminine third-declension nouns.
That is useful to know because their endings are not as predictable for beginners as first- or second-declension nouns.
Could salus mean more than just safety?
Yes. Salus can mean several related things, depending on context:
- safety
- well-being
- health
- welfare
- sometimes even salvation
In this sentence, safety or welfare fits best. Latin words often have a broader range of meaning than a single English translation.
If Latin wants to say who has the obligation, how would it do that with servanda est?
With the passive periphrastic, Latin often uses the dative of agent.
For example:
- nobis salus servanda est = we must preserve safety
literally, safety is to be preserved by us
So if no person is named, as in your sentence, the obligation is left general or impersonal:
- salus quoque servanda est = safety too must be preserved
Is the word order special here?
It is fairly natural Latin word order, but it also gives a neat rhetorical balance:
- Libertas grata est
- sed salus quoque servanda est
The first clause is simple: subject + adjective + est.
The second mirrors it, but uses the stronger necessity construction servanda est.
Also, placing quoque right after salus emphasizes that safety too deserves attention.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Libertas grata est, sed salus quoque servanda est to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions