Breakdown of Taberna contra bibliothecam stat, et discipula ibi chartam novam emere vult.
Questions & Answers about Taberna contra bibliothecam stat, et discipula ibi chartam novam emere vult.
Why is bibliothecam in the accusative?
Because contra takes the accusative case. So contra bibliothecam means opposite the library or across from the library.
- bibliotheca = library
- bibliothecam = accusative singular of bibliotheca
This is one of those cases where a preposition controls the case of the noun after it.
What does contra mean here?
Here contra means opposite or across from in a spatial sense.
A learner may first meet contra as against, and that is also a common meaning. But with places, it can mean:
- opposite
- facing
- across from
So Taberna contra bibliothecam stat means the shop is located opposite the library.
Why does Latin use stat instead of est?
Stat comes from stare, meaning to stand. Latin often uses stare for buildings or objects that are standing in a place.
So:
- taberna est = the shop is
- taberna stat = the shop stands / is situated
In English we usually just say is, but Latin often prefers the more vivid stands for physical location.
What case is taberna, and why?
Taberna is nominative singular. It is the subject of stat.
So in the first clause:
- taberna = the shop
- stat = stands
The thing doing the action of standing is the subject, so it is in the nominative.
Why is discipula nominative?
Discipula is nominative because it is the subject of vult.
The second clause is:
- discipula = the student / schoolgirl
- vult = wants
- emere = to buy
The same person who wants is also the person who buys, so Latin does not need to repeat a separate subject for emere.
What does ibi mean, and what does it refer to?
Ibi is an adverb meaning there or in that place.
Here it most naturally refers to the place just mentioned, probably the shop. So the sense is that the student wants to buy the paper there, at that location.
Because ibi is an adverb, it does not change its form.
Why is chartam novam in the accusative?
Because it is the direct object of emere.
The student wants to buy what?
Answer: chartam novam
So both words are accusative singular feminine:
- chartam = paper / a sheet of paper
- novam = new
The adjective novam matches chartam in:
- gender: feminine
- number: singular
- case: accusative
That agreement is a basic rule in Latin adjectives.
Why is emere an infinitive?
Because it depends on vult.
Latin commonly uses a complementary infinitive after verbs like:
- vult = wants
- potest = is able
- debet = ought
So:
- vult emere = wants to buy
This works very much like English wants to buy.
What form is vult?
Vult is the 3rd person singular present active indicative of velle, meaning to want.
So here it means:
- he wants
- she wants
- it wants
Since the subject is discipula, the meaning is she wants.
Why is there no separate word for she?
Latin often leaves subject pronouns out because the verb ending already tells you the person and number.
In vult, the ending shows 3rd person singular. Then discipula tells you who that person is.
So Latin does not need to say ea vult unless it wants special emphasis.
Why is the word order different from English?
Latin word order is much freer than English word order because the endings show the grammatical relationships.
For example:
- Taberna contra bibliothecam stat
- Contra bibliothecam taberna stat
- Stat taberna contra bibliothecam
All of these could express roughly the same basic idea, though the emphasis may differ.
A few helpful observations:
- Latin often puts the verb near the end.
- Important or topical words may be placed earlier.
- English depends much more on word order, while Latin depends much more on endings.
Does charta mean exactly paper?
Not always exactly. Charta can mean several related things, depending on context:
- paper
- a sheet of paper
- a page
- a document
- sometimes a letter
In this sentence, chartam novam emere most likely means buying new paper or a new sheet of paper, though the exact English wording depends on context.
Is et just connecting two full clauses?
Yes. Et means and, and here it joins two clauses:
- Taberna contra bibliothecam stat
- discipula ibi chartam novam emere vult
Each clause has its own main verb:
- stat
- vult
So this is a straightforward compound sentence.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Taberna contra bibliothecam stat, et discipula ibi chartam novam emere vult to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions