Breakdown of Post longam horam requies brevis discipulis valde bona est.
Questions & Answers about Post longam horam requies brevis discipulis valde bona est.
Why is post followed by longam horam?
Because post is a preposition that takes the accusative case when it means after.
So:
- post = after
- horam = hour in the accusative singular
- longam matches horam in case, number, and gender, so it also becomes accusative singular
That is why Latin uses post longam horam for after a long hour.
Why is it longam horam and not longa hora?
Because the phrase is the object of the preposition post, and post requires the accusative.
Compare:
- longa hora = a long hour, as a subject or in some other nominative use
- longam horam = a long hour, in the accusative after post
English does not show this change very much, but Latin does.
What is the subject of the sentence?
The subject is requies brevis.
You can tell because:
- requies is nominative singular
- brevis agrees with it in nominative singular feminine
- the verb est is singular, matching that subject
So the sentence is about a short rest.
Why is it requies brevis and not requiem brevem?
Because here the phrase is the subject, not a direct object.
Latin uses the nominative for the subject:
- requies = rest, in the nominative
- brevis = short, agreeing with requies
If it were a direct object, then you would expect accusative forms such as requiem brevem.
Why does brevis not look like longam or bona?
Because brevis belongs to a different adjective pattern.
Latin adjectives are not all declined the same way:
- longus, longa, longum and bonus, bona, bonum are first/second-declension adjectives
- brevis, breve is a third-declension adjective
So even though longam, brevis, and bona are all adjectives, they do not all have the same endings.
Here:
- brevis is nominative singular feminine, agreeing with requies
- it does not need to look like bona, because it comes from a different declension pattern
Why is bona feminine singular?
Because it describes requies, which is a feminine singular noun.
Latin adjectives must agree with the noun they describe in:
- gender
- number
- case
So:
- requies = feminine singular nominative
- bona = feminine singular nominative
That is why Latin says bona est, not bonum est or bonus est.
What is discipulis doing in the sentence?
Discipulis is in the dative plural and means for the students.
This is a very common Latin use of the dative: the dative of advantage or reference.
So the sentence is not saying that the students are the subject. Instead, it means that the short rest is good for them.
- discipuli = the students
- discipulis = to/for the students
Why doesn’t Latin use a word like for before discipulis?
Because Latin often expresses ideas like for someone just by using the dative case.
English usually needs a separate word such as for, but Latin can often do the same job with an ending.
So:
- English: good for the students
- Latin: discipulis bona
The ending -is in discipulis shows its function.
What does valde modify?
Valde modifies bona.
It means very, so:
- bona est = is good
- valde bona est = is very good
In other words, valde strengthens the adjective bona.
Why is the verb est at the end?
Because Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order.
Latin often puts the verb at or near the end, especially in straightforward prose. That does not change the basic meaning.
So:
- requies brevis discipulis valde bona est
- and some other word orders
can mean the same thing, as long as the endings make the grammar clear.
The chosen order here gives a natural flow:
- first the time phrase: post longam horam
- then the subject: requies brevis
- then who it concerns: discipulis
- then the description: valde bona
- finally the verb: est
Could the words be rearranged and still mean the same thing?
Yes, often they could.
Because Latin relies heavily on case endings, the sentence can usually survive some rearrangement without changing its core meaning.
For example, these would still be understandable Latin:
- Requies brevis post longam horam discipulis valde bona est.
- Discipulis post longam horam requies brevis valde bona est.
However, word order still matters for emphasis and style. The original sentence puts post longam horam first, which emphasizes the idea of after a long hour.
Is requies a common kind of noun? It looks unusual.
It is a third-declension noun, and yes, it may look less familiar at first if you have mostly seen first- and second-declension nouns.
Its dictionary form is requies, requietis, feminine, meaning rest.
That helps explain why:
- the nominative singular is requies
- the adjective agreeing with it is feminine: brevis, bona
So the form is perfectly normal, just from a different declension pattern than nouns like puella or servus.
Why are there two adjectives with requies: brevis and bona?
Because they do two different jobs.
- brevis directly describes the noun requies: a short rest
- bona works with est to say something about the subject: is good
So the structure is:
- requies brevis = the short rest
- discipulis valde bona est = is very good for the students
This is similar to English in:
- The short rest is very good for the students.
Here short is attached directly to rest, while good comes after is.
How do I know that bona is a predicate adjective and not just another adjective attached to requies?
The verb est tells you that.
In requies brevis discipulis valde bona est, bona is linked to the subject by est, so it is a predicate adjective: it tells you what the subject is.
If both adjectives were simply attached to the noun, the structure would feel different. Here the meaning is clearly:
- the short rest = subject
- is very good = statement about the subject
So brevis is attributive, while bona is predicative.
How would you break the sentence into its main parts?
A helpful breakdown is:
- Post longam horam = after a long hour
- requies brevis = a short rest
- discipulis = for the students
- valde bona est = is very good
So the grammar works like this:
- time phrase
- subject
- dative phrase
- predicate with verb
This is a good way to read Latin: identify the prepositional phrase, subject, indirect/dative phrase, and main verb.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Post longam horam requies brevis discipulis valde bona est to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions