Breakdown of kono tana nara, hon wo takusan simaeru.
Questions & Answers about kono tana nara, hon wo takusan simaeru.
What does なら mean here?
Here, なら means something like if it’s this shelf or as for this shelf.
It often brings up a topic and gives a judgment about it. In this sentence:
- この棚なら = if it’s this shelf / this shelf, at least
- It suggests comparison with other shelves: maybe other shelves are too small, weak, or unsuitable.
So the nuance is not just identifying the shelf. It is more like:
- This shelf should work
- This shelf, on the other hand, can handle it
Why is there a comma after なら?
What is 棚 exactly? Does it mean shelf or bookcase?
棚 literally means shelf. Depending on context, it can refer to:
- a single shelf
- a shelving unit
- a bookcase-like piece of furniture
So in English, the best translation may vary:
- shelf
- bookcase
- shelving unit
In this sentence, since it talks about storing many books, English might naturally say bookcase or shelf, depending on the situation.
Why is it 本をたくさん and not たくさん本を?
Both are possible.
- 本をたくさんしまえる
- たくさん本をしまえる
Both mean basically the same thing: can store a lot of books.
The version in your sentence, 本をたくさん, keeps 本 directly connected to を, which is very common and natural. Japanese word order is flexible, especially with adverbs like たくさん.
So this is a word-order issue, not a grammar mistake.
What is しまえる? Is it from しまう?
Yes. しまえる is the potential form of しまう.
- dictionary form: しまう
- potential form: しまえる
So:
- しまう = to put away / store
- しまえる = can put away / can store
In this sentence, しまえる means can store or has enough capacity to store.
What kind of can is しまえる? Does it mean ability, permission, or possibility?
Here it means possibility/capacity, not permission.
So it is not:
- You are allowed to store books here
It is more like:
- This shelf is capable of storing a lot of books
- A lot of books will fit in this shelf/bookcase
- You can store a lot of books in this shelf
The focus is on the shelf being suitable or having enough space.
Why is the object marked with を even though the verb is in the potential form?
Great question. With potential forms, Japanese sometimes uses either が or を, depending on the verb and the style.
Here:
- 本をたくさんしまえる
is completely natural.
With potential expressions, learners often hear that the object changes to が, but in real Japanese, を is also common with many potential verbs, especially in everyday speech.
So this sentence is normal Japanese. You do not need to think of it as wrong or unusual.
Who is doing the storing? Is the subject missing?
Yes, the subject is omitted, which is very common in Japanese.
The sentence does not explicitly say who can store the books. Depending on context, it could mean:
- I can store a lot of books in this shelf
- You can store a lot of books in this shelf
- We can store a lot of books in this shelf
- or more generally, this shelf can hold a lot of books
Japanese often leaves out information that is obvious from context.
Does しまう here mean the same thing as put away, not the finish doing meaning?
Why use しまえる instead of something like 入る?
They are similar, but the nuance is slightly different.
- 入る = fit / go in
- しまえる = can store / can put away
Compare:
この棚なら、本がたくさん入る。
= A lot of books will fit on/in this shelf.この棚なら、本をたくさんしまえる。
= With this shelf, you can store a lot of books.
入る focuses more on physical capacity.
しまえる focuses more on storing/putting things away neatly in it.
Is たくさん an adjective here?
Could this sentence also mean This shelf can hold a lot of books?
Yes. That is a very natural English translation.
Even though the Japanese literally uses can store, English often prefers:
- This shelf can hold a lot of books
- You can fit a lot of books on this shelf
- This shelf can store a lot of books
All of these can match the Japanese, depending on context and translation style.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from kono tana nara, hon wo takusan simaeru to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions