Breakdown of kono kusuri ni ha kouka ga aru.
Questions & Answers about kono kusuri ni ha kouka ga aru.
What does には mean here? Why are both に and は used after 薬?
には is に + は.
- に marks the thing something applies to, like for / in / with regard to
- は marks that whole phrase as the topic or adds contrast/emphasis
So この薬には効果がある means something like:
- As for this medicine, it has an effect
- This medicine does have an effect
- There is an effect in/with this medicine
In natural English, we usually just say This medicine is effective or This medicine works.
Using には often gives a slight sense of with this medicine or at least in this medicine / as for this medicine.
Why is it 効果がある and not 効果はある?
In 効果がある, 効果 is the thing that exists.
The basic pattern is:
- X が ある = there is X / X exists
So:
- 効果がある = there is an effect
Here, ある is not just to exist in a physical sense. It often means to be present, to be possessed, or to occur.
If you said 効果はある, that would put effect itself in the topic/contrast position, as in:
- There is an effect, at least
- As for the effect, it exists
That is possible in the right context, but 効果がある is the normal neutral phrasing.
Why is に used with 効果がある? I thought に often meant to or in a location.
に has several uses. Here it does not mean movement to a place.
In this sentence, に marks the thing in which, for which, or with regard to which the effect exists.
So:
- この薬に効果がある = This medicine has an effect / There is an effect in this medicine
This use of に often appears with ある when talking about something being present in or associated with something.
It is a bit different from literal location, but related.
Why not say この薬は効果がある instead of この薬には効果がある?
You can say この薬は効果がある, and it is understandable. But この薬には効果がある is more natural and idiomatic.
The difference is subtle:
この薬は効果がある
= This medicine is effective
More direct, but slightly less standard in this exact pattern.この薬には効果がある
= This medicine has an effect / This medicine is effective
Feels more like with this medicine, there is an effect
Also, には can suggest contrast:
- この薬には効果があるが、あの薬にはない。
This medicine is effective, but that one isn’t.
So には is very common here.
What exactly does ある mean in this sentence?
Normally, learners first meet ある as to exist for non-living things:
- 本がある = There is a book
But ある also has broader meanings such as:
- to have
- to exist
- to be present
- to occur
So in 効果がある, it means:
- there is an effect
- an effect is present
- it has effectiveness
That is why the whole sentence can be translated naturally as:
- This medicine is effective
- This medicine works
Could I say この薬は効く instead?
Yes. この薬は効く is a very common and natural sentence.
It means:
- This medicine works
- This medicine is effective
The nuance is a little different:
- この薬には効果がある sounds a bit more formal or objective
- この薬は効く sounds more direct and conversational
So both are correct, but they are used in slightly different styles.
Why isn’t it この薬の効果がある?
Because この薬の効果 means the effect of this medicine, which is a noun phrase.
For example:
- この薬の効果は高い。
The effect of this medicine is strong.
But in your sentence, the meaning is not the medicine’s effect exists as a possessed noun phrase. Instead, it is saying that there is effectiveness in this medicine.
That is why Japanese uses:
- この薬には効果がある
not:
- この薬の効果がある
The latter sounds unnatural in this context.
What are the readings of the kanji in this sentence?
The sentence is read:
- この くすり には こうか が ある。
Word by word:
- この = this
- 薬(くすり) = medicine
- 効果(こうか) = effect / effectiveness
- ある = to exist / to have
So the full reading is:
- このくすりにはこうかがある。
Is there any special nuance from using この here?
この means this, and it must be followed by a noun:
- この薬 = this medicine
It refers to a medicine close to the speaker, or one currently being discussed.
Compare:
- この薬 = this medicine
- その薬 = that medicine (near the listener / previously mentioned)
- あの薬 = that medicine over there
So この is just identifying which medicine we are talking about.
Does this sentence sound formal or casual?
It is grammatically plain, but the wording is somewhat neutral or slightly formal because of 効果がある.
- この薬には効果がある。
plain style, neutral/objective - この薬には効果があります。
polite style
In everyday speech, people may more often say:
- この薬、効くよ。
- この薬は効きます。
So the sentence you have is natural, but it sounds a little more like explanatory, written, or factual language.
Can this sentence imply contrast?
Yes, especially because of には.
は often creates a contrastive feeling, even if it is subtle. So この薬には効果がある may suggest something like:
- This medicine, at least, is effective
- This medicine does have an effect
That contrast may or may not be important depending on context.
For example:
- この薬には効果があるけど、あの薬には効果がない。
This medicine is effective, but that medicine is not.
Without context, the sentence can still be understood simply as a neutral statement.
How would I make this negative or past?
Using the same pattern:
Negative
- この薬には効果がない。
This medicine has no effect. / This medicine is not effective.
Past
- この薬には効果があった。
This medicine was effective. / This medicine had an effect.
Polite negative
- この薬には効果がありません。
Polite past
- この薬には効果がありました。
The core expression stays the same:
- 効果がある
- 効果がない
- 効果があった
Why are there spaces in the sentence? Does Japanese normally write like that?
No. Japanese is normally written without spaces.
So the normal written form is:
- この薬には効果がある。
Spaces are often added in teaching materials to help beginners see the parts more clearly:
- この 薬 に は 効果 が ある。
That spacing is just for learning. In real Japanese writing, you usually will not see it.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from kono kusuri ni ha kouka ga aru to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions