Breakdown of sono uwasa ha matigai desita.
Questions & Answers about sono uwasa ha matigai desita.
Why is その used here?
その means that and points to something close to the listener, already mentioned, or known from the context.
So その噂 means that rumor or the rumor we’re talking about.
A learner might compare it with:
- この噂 = this rumor
- その噂 = that rumor
- あの噂 = that rumor over there / that rumor more distant from both speaker and listener
In many real conversations, その often means the one you just mentioned.
Why is there a は after 噂?
は marks the topic of the sentence.
So その噂は means something like:
- As for that rumor, ...
- About that rumor, ...
It does not simply mark the subject in the same way English does. It sets up that rumor as the thing being talked about.
A very literal breakdown would be:
- その噂 = that rumor
- は = as for
- 間違いでした = was wrong / was mistaken / was false
Why is it 間違い and not an adjective like 間違った?
間違い is a noun meaning mistake or error.
In this sentence, Japanese uses a noun + the copula:
- 間違いでした = was a mistake / was incorrect
This is very natural in Japanese. English often prefers was wrong or was false, but Japanese can express that idea with the noun 間違い.
So the sentence is not literally built like the rumor was wrong with an adjective. It is more like:
- That rumor was an error / was mistaken
Even though the natural English translation may sound more adjectival, the Japanese structure is nominal.
Why is it でした instead of です?
でした is the past polite form of the copula.
- です = is
- でした = was
So:
- その噂は間違いです。 = That rumor is wrong.
- その噂は間違いでした。 = That rumor was wrong.
In actual use, the past form can also suggest it turned out to be wrong after the facts became clear.
Does でした always mean past time here?
Usually yes, but in context it can feel a little broader than simple past tense in English.
For example, その噂は間違いでした can mean:
- the rumor was wrong
- the rumor turned out to be false
- that rumor was mistaken after all
So it often implies that someone believed or discussed the rumor before, and later learned it was incorrect.
Is 間違いでした the same as 間違っていました?
They are similar, but not exactly the same.
- 間違いでした uses the noun 間違い
- 間違っていました uses the verb 間違う in a progressive/result form
Both can often be translated as was wrong, but the nuance is a little different.
その噂は間違いでした。
- sounds like That rumor was false / was a mistake
その噂は間違っていました。
- sounds more like That rumor was incorrect
The first is very common and natural when judging information as false. The second is possible too, but 間違いでした is often the more straightforward phrasing here.
Why isn’t there a particle between その and 噂?
What exactly does 噂 mean? Is it always negative?
噂 means rumor, gossip, or hearsay.
It often has the nuance of information spreading informally, not necessarily confirmed as true. Because of that, it can sometimes sound unreliable from the start.
It is not always strongly negative, but it often suggests:
- people are talking about something
- the information may not be verified
- it may be gossip rather than firm fact
So using 間違いでした with 噂 is very natural, because rumors are the kind of thing that can later turn out to be false.
Could this sentence be said without は?
You could change the particle, but the meaning and emphasis would shift.
For example:
その噂は間違いでした。
As for that rumor, it was false.
This is the most neutral and natural version.その噂が間違いでした。
This sounds more contrastive or identifying, like It was that rumor that was false.
It is less neutral in this context.
So は is the most natural choice when simply making a statement about the rumor.
Is this sentence polite?
Yes. It is in the polite style because of でした.
Compare:
- その噂は間違いでした。 = polite
- その噂は間違いだった。 = plain
The polite version is suitable for normal conversation, reporting, and speaking respectfully. The plain version is more casual and would be used with friends, in informal writing, or inner thoughts.
What is the most literal breakdown of the sentence?
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from sono uwasa ha matigai desita to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions