Breakdown of Saya suka kisah masa kecil nenek saya.
Questions & Answers about Saya suka kisah masa kecil nenek saya.
The sentence Saya suka kisah masa kecil nenek saya breaks down like this:
- Saya = I / me
- suka = like
- kisah = story / tale
- masa kecil = childhood (literally: period + small)
- nenek saya = my grandmother
So the structure is:
- Subject: Saya
- Verb: suka
- Object: kisah masa kecil nenek saya
Literally: I like story period-small grandmother my → I like the story of my grandmother’s childhood.
In Indonesian, possessive relationships are usually:
possessed + possessor
So:
- nenek saya = grandmother + I = my grandmother
- rumah saya = house + I = my house
- ibu mereka = mother + they = their mother
Putting saya first (saya nenek) does not mean my grandmother; it just sounds like two separate nouns and is not correct as a possessive.
Another common way to show possession is:
- nenek saya = my grandmother
- nenekku = my grandmother (using the suffix -ku, more informal/written)
But the core pattern is always: thing + owner.
Let’s go step by step:
- masa = period / time
- kecil = small; in this phrase, it functions like child‑ (childhood)
→ masa kecil = childhood - nenek saya = my grandmother
Now combine:
- masa kecil nenek saya
= (masa kecil) + (nenek saya)
= childhood + my grandmother
= my grandmother’s childhood
Indonesian often strings nouns like this:
- rumah nenek saya = my grandmother’s house
- masa kecil adik saya = my younger sibling’s childhood
So X Y Z often means Z’s Y X in English.
They are very close, and in many contexts you can use either:
kisah
- story, tale
- often feels a bit more narrative, sometimes more emotional or serious
- often used with life stories, love stories, religious stories
- examples: kisah hidupnya (the story of his/her life), kisah cinta (love story)
cerita
- story, a telling, a narrative
- very common and neutral, used for everyday stories, jokes, etc.
- examples: cerita pendek (short story), cerita lucu (funny story)
In this sentence:
- Saya suka kisah masa kecil nenek saya.
You could also say:- Saya suka cerita masa kecil nenek saya.
Both are natural. Kisah might sound just a bit more like a life story / touching story.
Indonesian nouns usually do not show plural by changing form. So:
- kisah can mean a story, the story, or stories, depending on context.
In your sentence:
- Saya suka kisah masa kecil nenek saya.
This could be understood as:
- I like the story of my grandmother’s childhood, or
- I like stories about my grandmother’s childhood.
If you really want to emphasize plural, you can say:
- kisah‑kisah masa kecil nenek saya (stories of my grandmother’s childhood)
- banyak kisah masa kecil nenek saya (many stories about my grandmother’s childhood)
The repetition kisah‑kisah or a word like banyak often signals plural.
In Indonesian, descriptive words (adjectives) usually come after the noun:
- masa kecil = small period → childhood
- rumah besar = big house
- buku baru = new book
- anak nakal = naughty child
So the pattern is usually:
noun + adjective
In your sentence:
- masa (period) + kecil (small)
→ masa kecil (childhood)
This is normal word order for Indonesian.
You can, and it is grammatically correct:
- Saya suka kisah masa kecil nenek saya.
- Saya menyukai kisah masa kecil nenek saya.
Differences:
suka
- very common, everyday, neutral
- slightly more flexible, can be used almost like an adjective:
- Saya suka kopi. (I like coffee.)
- Dia suka marah. (He/she often gets angry / tends to be angry.)
menyukai
- more clearly a verb to like / to favor
- sounds a bit more formal or written
- used more in formal writing, news, essays, or to sound a bit more serious
In normal conversation, Saya suka … is more natural.
Yes, in the right context. Indonesian often drops the subject when it is clear from context:
- (Saya) suka kisah masa kecil nenek saya.
- (Dia) suka kisah masa kecil neneknya.
Without Saya, Suka kisah masa kecil nenek saya. would usually still be understood as I like …, but:
- it feels a bit more incomplete or casual, like an answer or comment, not a standalone statement.
it is common in spoken Indonesian or in chat/text, especially as a response:
- A: Kamu suka apa? (What do you like?)
- B: Suka kisah masa kecil nenek saya. (Like my grandmother’s childhood stories.)
For clear, full sentences (especially in writing or learning), it is better to keep Saya.
You can, but the nuance changes slightly:
kisah masa kecil nenek saya
- very natural, compact
- literally: story of childhood [of] my grandmother
- the standard, preferred way
kisah masa kecil dari nenek saya
- literally: childhood story from my grandmother
- sounds more like stories that my grandmother tells about childhood (maybe her own, maybe others), depending on context
So:
If you mean my grandmother’s childhood (as a time in her life), use:
kisah masa kecil nenek sayaIf you mean stories that come from my grandmother (she is the storyteller), say:
kisah dari nenek saya
or
kisah masa kecil dari nenek saya (if you mean childhood stories she tells).
Nenek mainly means:
grandmother (in a family context)
- nenek saya = my grandmother
In some contexts, it can be used like granny / old lady, either:
- affectionately: calling an older woman Nenek (like saying Gran), or
- descriptively: nenek itu = that old woman / that granny
In your sentence, because of saya:
- nenek saya is very clearly my grandmother, not just any old woman.
That word order is not natural in Indonesian. The usual way is:
- kisah masa kecil nenek saya (correct and natural)
Trying to say:
- kisah nenek saya masa kecil
sounds awkward and unclear, because:
- Indonesian prefers the more consistent order [main noun] + [descriptor(s)]
- masa kecil nenek saya is a neat, clear noun phrase: my grandmother’s childhood
If you want a variation, there are other natural options:
- Saya suka kisah tentang masa kecil nenek saya.
= I like stories about my grandmother’s childhood.
But you should not move masa kecil to the end like in your example.
Yes. You can adjust:
The pronoun Saya → Aku (more informal/intimate)
- Aku suka kisah masa kecil nenek aku. (spoken, casual)
- Aku suka kisah masa kecil nenekku. (also casual; -ku is an informal possessive suffix)
Both subject and possessive more informally:
- Aku suka kisah masa kecil nenek aku.
- Aku suka kisah masa kecil nenekku.
Note:
- Saya … nenek saya = neutral / polite
- Aku … nenekku = more intimate, to friends, family, same age, etc.