Question 1

What does the expression bahu-membahu mean here, literally and idiomatically?

Accepted Answer

Literally it is shoulder-to-shoulder. Idiomatically it means to cooperate closely, to work together, often with a sense of solidarity in facing difficulty. It does not require actual physical contact.

Question 2

Is bahu-membahu formal, informal, or neutral? Are there good synonyms?

Accepted Answer

It’s neutral and common in both spoken and written Indonesian. Useful synonyms:
- bekerja sama (work together; very general)
- bergotong-royong or gotong royong (mutual aid, often community-oriented)
- berkolaborasi (collaborate; more formal/technical)

Question 3

Do I need to add saling (each other) before bahu-membahu?

Accepted Answer

No. bahu-membahu itself already encodes mutual action. You may see saling bahu-membahu in real-life usage; it’s acceptable but a bit redundant and more emphatic.

Question 4

Can bahu-membahu take a direct object? How do I expand the idea?

Accepted Answer

It’s intransitive by itself. To say what they are working together on, add another verb or a prepositional phrase:
- bahu-membahu mengatasi masalah (work together to overcome the problem)
- bahu-membahu untuk memperbaiki generator (work together to fix the generator)
- bahu-membahu dalam keadaan darurat (work together in an emergency)

Question 5

Why is there no word for “is” in listrik padam?

Accepted Answer

Indonesian often omits a copula (is/are) with adjectives and certain stative verbs. padam means out/extinguished. So listrik padam = the electricity is out, with no linking verb needed.

Question 6

What’s the nuance difference between padam and mati for power going out?

Accepted Answer

Both are used. padam is a bit more formal/neutral (used for lights, fire, power). mati is more colloquial; you’ll hear mati lampu (power outage) a lot. listrik padam and listrik mati both sound natural.

Question 7

What does masih add here, and how does it compare to tetap or terus?

Accepted Answer

- masih = still (continuation from a prior state): they are still working together.
- tetap = remain/keep (stresses persistence despite obstacles): they remain working together.
- terus = keep on/continue (continuous action): they keep working. With bahu-membahu, masih or tetap sound more natural than terus.

Question 8

Where should masih go, and how do I negate this idea?

Accepted Answer

Place masih before the predicate: Tim kecil itu masih bahu-membahu. For negatives:
- masih tidak = still not (They still are not…)
- tidak lagi = no longer (They are no longer…)
Example: Tim kecil itu tidak lagi bahu-membahu (They no longer work together).

Question 9

What does itu do after tim kecil? Is it “that” or “the”?

Accepted Answer

Post-nominal itu marks the noun as specific/definite: that small team / the small team (known to the speakers). ini would mean this (near the speaker). In formal writing, tersebut also marks definiteness: tim kecil tersebut.

Question 10

Why is kecil after tim? Could I use yang?

Accepted Answer

Adjectives normally follow nouns in Indonesian: tim kecil (small team). yang is used to introduce relative clauses or to add emphasis/contrast; tim yang kecil is possible but tends to contrast with another team (the one that is small).

Question 11

If I want “a small team,” do I need a word like “a/an”?

Accepted Answer

You can add a classifier like sebuah: sebuah tim kecil = a small team. But Indonesian often omits it when context makes it clear. Note: tim kecilnya usually means his/her/the small team (definite, sometimes possessive); use with care.

Question 12

How does meskipun work here? Can I use other words, and do I need tetapi in the main clause?

Accepted Answer

meskipun means although/even though. Synonyms: walaupun, meski/ walau (slightly shorter), biarpun (colloquial), kendati (formal). You can write either:
- Main clause first: … meskipun …
- Or start with the concessive clause: Meskipun listrik padam, …
Adding tetapi/namun in the main clause is optional for emphasis: Meskipun…, namun…

Question 13

Could I drop masih without changing the grammar? What nuance changes?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Tim kecil itu bahu-membahu meskipun listrik padam is fine. Dropping masih removes the “still/continuation” nuance and simply states they work together despite the outage.

Question 14

Does the sentence express present or past time?

Accepted Answer

Indonesian doesn’t inflect for tense. Time is inferred or marked lexically:
- Past: tadi, kemarin, sudah (already)
- Progressive: sedang
- Ongoing from before: masih
So you adjust with time words as needed.

Question 15

Does tim kecil itu imply multiple people even without a plural marker?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Indonesian doesn’t require plural marking; tim already implies multiple members. If you want to highlight the people, you can say para anggota tim kecil itu (the team members).

Question 16

What pattern is bahu-membahu an example of, and are there similar forms?

Accepted Answer

It’s a reduplicated/affixed pair that conveys reciprocity (mutual action), e.g.:
- tolong-menolong (help each other)
- hormat-menghormati (respect one another)
- pukul-memukul, sikut-menyikut (hit/jostle one another)
These typically don’t need saling, though adding it is common for emphasis.

Tim kecil itu masih bahu-membahu meskipun listrik padam.

Breakdown of Tim kecil itu masih bahu-membahu meskipun listrik padam.

Questions & Answers about Tim kecil itu masih bahu-membahu meskipun listrik padam.

More from this lesson

Master Indonesian — from Tim kecil itu masih bahu-membahu meskipun listrik padam to fluency