Breakdown of Sekolah itu tidak punya guru tua lagi.
Questions & Answers about Sekolah itu tidak punya guru tua lagi.
Why does itu come after sekolah instead of before it?
In Indonesian, demonstratives like ini and itu usually come after the noun.
- sekolah itu = that school / the school
- guru itu = that teacher / the teacher
So sekolah itu is the normal Indonesian order. In many contexts, itu can also make the noun feel more definite, so it can sometimes sound like the school, not just that school.
Why is tidak used here, not bukan?
Because tidak is used to negate verbs, adjectives, and some other predicates, while bukan is mainly used to negate nouns or noun phrases.
Here, punya means to have, which is a verb, so:
- tidak punya = do not have
Compare:
- Sekolah itu tidak punya guru tua lagi. = That school no longer has old teachers.
- Itu bukan sekolah. = That is not a school.
So bukan punya would be wrong here.
Is punya the normal word for to have?
Yes, punya is very common in everyday Indonesian and often means to have or to own.
So:
- Sekolah itu punya guru tua. = That school has old teachers.
However, punya is somewhat less formal than memiliki.
- punya = common, everyday
- memiliki = more formal, written, official
A more formal version of the sentence would be:
- Sekolah itu tidak memiliki guru tua lagi.
Both are understandable, but punya is extremely common in speech.
Why is it guru tua and not tua guru?
Because in Indonesian, adjectives usually come after the noun they describe.
So:
- guru tua = old teacher / old teachers
- rumah besar = big house
- buku baru = new book
This is the normal word order:
- noun + adjective
Does guru tua mean old teachers in age, or could it mean senior teachers?
It can mean either, depending on context.
Literally, tua means old. So guru tua most directly means teachers who are old.
But in real usage, tua can sometimes suggest:
- older in age
- senior
- long-serving
- experienced
If the context is unclear, a learner should usually understand guru tua as old teachers, but native speakers may sometimes interpret it more broadly as older/senior teachers.
What does lagi mean here? I thought it meant again.
Lagi often does mean again, but with a negative sentence it commonly means anymore or no longer.
So:
- tidak ... lagi = no longer ... / not ... anymore
In this sentence:
- Sekolah itu tidak punya guru tua lagi.
- = That school no longer has old teachers.
- = That school doesn't have old teachers anymore.
This is a very common pattern in Indonesian.
Examples:
- Saya tidak bekerja lagi. = I no longer work.
- Dia tidak tinggal di sini lagi. = He/She doesn't live here anymore.
Does guru here mean one teacher or more than one teacher?
Indonesian nouns usually do not have to show singular or plural. So guru can mean:
- teacher
- teachers
The exact number depends on context.
In this sentence, English may translate it as old teachers because that sounds natural with the overall meaning, but grammatically Indonesian itself does not force singular or plural here.
If someone wanted to make the plural explicit, they could say:
- guru-guru tua = old teachers
But Indonesian often leaves this unmarked.
Why isn’t there a word for the or a?
Indonesian does not use articles the way English does. There is no direct equivalent used in every sentence for a/an and the.
So:
- sekolah can mean a school or the school
- guru can mean a teacher, the teacher, or teachers
Context usually tells you which meaning is intended.
In this sentence, itu helps make sekolah more definite:
- sekolah itu = that school / the school
But guru tua does not need any article.
Could this sentence also be said with ada instead of punya?
Yes. A very natural alternative is:
- Di sekolah itu tidak ada guru tua lagi.
This means roughly:
- There are no old teachers at that school anymore.
The difference is:
- tidak punya focuses on having
- tidak ada focuses on existence/presence
So:
- Sekolah itu tidak punya guru tua lagi. = That school no longer has old teachers.
- Di sekolah itu tidak ada guru tua lagi. = There are no old teachers at that school anymore.
Both are natural, though the version with ada may sound especially common in everyday speech when talking about who is present at a place.
Is sekolah itu tidak punya guru tua lagi a complete and natural sentence in Indonesian?
Yes, it is complete and understandable. It sounds natural in everyday Indonesian.
That said, depending on context, some speakers might prefer slightly different wording, such as:
- Sekolah itu sudah tidak punya guru tua lagi.
- Di sekolah itu tidak ada guru tua lagi.
Adding sudah can make the no longer idea even clearer:
- sudah tidak ... lagi = already no longer ...
But the original sentence is still perfectly valid.
What is the overall sentence structure here?
The structure is:
- Sekolah itu = subject/topic, that school
- tidak punya = negated verb, does not have
- guru tua = object, old teacher(s)
- lagi = anymore / no longer
So the sentence is basically:
- [Subject] + [not have] + [object] + [anymore]
In a word-by-word gloss:
- Sekolah = school
- itu = that / the
- tidak = not
- punya = have
- guru = teacher
- tua = old
- lagi = anymore / no longer
That gives:
- That school does not have old teachers anymore.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning IndonesianMaster Indonesian — from Sekolah itu tidak punya guru tua lagi to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions