Breakdown of Der Trainer sagt, der Dienstplan sei inzwischen online.
sein
to be
sagen
to say
online
online
der Trainer
the coach
der Dienstplan
the duty roster
inzwischen
by now
Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about Der Trainer sagt, der Dienstplan sei inzwischen online.
Why is sei used instead of ist?
Because German marks reported speech with the subjunctive (Konjunktiv I). After a reporting verb like sagen, sei (subjunctive of sein) signals that the speaker is relaying someone else’s words rather than asserting a fact. Using ist is possible in everyday speech but does not explicitly mark reportedness.
What are the Konjunktiv I forms of sein?
- ich sei
- du seiest
- er/sie/es sei
- wir seien
- ihr seiet
- sie/Sie seien
Could I say Der Trainer sagt, dass der Dienstplan inzwischen online ist?
Yes. With dass, the verb goes to the end (… dass der Dienstplan inzwischen online ist). This version is very common in everyday speech. In formal writing, many prefer Konjunktiv I to keep a clear distance: … dass der Dienstplan inzwischen online sei.
Why isn’t the verb at the end after the comma?
Because there is no subordinating conjunction like dass. The reported clause here is a that-less clause with normal main-clause word order (verb in second position): der Dienstplan (subject) + sei (verb) + rest.
Can I use wäre instead of sei?
You can, but it slightly changes the feel. Wäre is Konjunktiv II. In reported speech, Konjunktiv I (sei) is preferred when its form is distinct from the indicative (which it is here). Wäre can sound more tentative or distant. In informal speech, some speakers default to wäre, but in careful style sei is the standard choice.
What happens if the reporting verb is in the past, e.g., sagte?
You normally keep Konjunktiv I for the reported content: Der Trainer sagte, der Dienstplan sei inzwischen online. This shows simultaneity (the schedule was online at the time of saying). If you need anteriority, you’d use the perfect in Konjunktiv I: … der Dienstplan sei inzwischen online gewesen.
How would this be in direct speech?
Use a colon and keep the indicative: Der Trainer sagt: Der Dienstplan ist inzwischen online. (In print you’d often add quotation marks.)
What does inzwischen mean, and where does it go?
It means by now/meanwhile/in the meantime and typically sits in the middle field: … ist inzwischen online. You can also front it for emphasis: Inzwischen ist der Dienstplan online. Closest synonyms: mittlerweile (very common), bereits (already, slightly more formal). Note that schon often overlaps but can imply earlier than expected.
Is online capitalized in German?
No, as an adjective/adverb it stays lowercase: online. In compounds before a noun, you’ll see Online- with a capital because the whole compound is a noun (e.g., der Online-Shop).
What gender and plural does Dienstplan have?
It’s masculine: der Dienstplan. Plural: die Dienstpläne (with Umlaut). Related words: der Schichtplan (shift rota), der Einsatzplan (deployment/assignment plan).
Why is there a comma after sagt?
German requires a comma to separate the reporting clause from the reported clause, even when the latter is a that-less (V2) clause: … sagt, der Dienstplan sei …. You’d also use a comma before dass if you choose that construction.
Can I say Der Trainer sagt, der Dienstplan würde inzwischen online sein?
Better not here. The würde-periphrasis is used in reported speech mainly to avoid form clashes or to express future/hypothetical meaning. Since sei is clear and unambiguous, würde … sein sounds roundabout or speculative in this sentence.