Breakdown of Wenn der Herbst beginnt, ändern sich die Farben der Stadt.
die Stadt
the city
beginnen
to begin
wenn
when
der Herbst
the autumn
sich ändern
to change
die Farbe
the color
Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about Wenn der Herbst beginnt, ändern sich die Farben der Stadt.
Why is der Herbst used instead of den Herbst?
Because Herbst is the subject of the subordinate clause Wenn der Herbst beginnt. Subjects in German take the nominative case, and the masculine nominative singular article for Herbst is der, not den (which is masculine accusative).
Why is beginnt placed at the end of the clause Wenn der Herbst beginnt?
Whenever you introduce a subordinate clause with a conjunction like wenn, the finite verb must go to the very end of that clause. This is standard German word order for subordinate clauses (verb-final).
Why is there a comma before ändern sich die Farben der Stadt?
German requires a comma to separate a subordinate clause from the main clause. Here, Wenn der Herbst beginnt is a subordinate clause, so you must place a comma before the main clause ändern sich die Farben der Stadt.
In ändern sich die Farben der Stadt, why does ändern come before sich?
After a comma, you’re in the main clause. German main clauses follow the Verb‑Second (V2) rule: the finite verb must occupy the second position. The entire preceding subordinate clause counts as the first position, so ändern (the finite verb) comes next, followed by the reflexive pronoun sich.
What case is der Stadt, and why is it that case?
der Stadt is in the genitive case. It expresses possession or relationship—literally “the colors of the city.” Stadt is feminine singular (die Stadt), and its genitive singular form is der Stadt.
What kind of verb is sich ändern, and why is sich necessary?
ändern in this context is a reflexive (pronominal) verb: sich ändern means “to change” (intransitive). The reflexive pronoun sich is required to complete its meaning; without it, ändern would need a direct object (“to alter something”).
Why is the present tense used here instead of past or future?
German regularly uses the present tense to describe habitual actions, general truths, or recurring events. Here it states a general pattern: whenever autumn begins, the city’s colors change.
Can you add dann after the comma, as in Wenn der Herbst beginnt, dann ändern sich…?
Yes. Adding dann is grammatically correct: Wenn der Herbst beginnt, dann ändern sich die Farben der Stadt. However, German speakers often omit dann because the sequence is already clear from the verb positions.
Could you use als instead of wenn in this sentence?
No. Als refers to a single, completed event in the past. Wenn is used for repeated or general conditions (present or future). Since the sentence describes a recurring phenomenon, wenn is the correct choice.