Questions & Answers about Der Plan ist geheim.
Why is it der Plan and not die Plan or das Plan?
Because Plan is a masculine noun in German. German nouns have grammatical gender, and Plan happens to be masculine, so in the nominative singular it takes der.
- der Plan = masculine
- die would be for a feminine noun
- das would be for a neuter noun
This is something you usually have to learn together with the noun: not just Plan, but der Plan.
What case is der in this sentence?
It is nominative case.
In Der Plan ist geheim, der Plan is the subject of the sentence, and the subject is normally in the nominative.
So:
- der Plan = nominative subject
- ist = verb
- geheim = predicate adjective describing the subject
Why is Plan capitalized?
Because all nouns are capitalized in German.
So:
- der Plan
- das Haus
- die Idee
This is a standard spelling rule in German, not something special about this sentence.
Why is the verb ist in the second position?
Because German main clauses usually follow the V2 rule: the finite verb comes in the second position.
In this sentence:
- Der Plan = first position
- ist = second position
- geheim = rest of the clause
So the structure is very normal German word order: Subject + verb + complement
Why doesn’t geheim have an adjective ending?
Because geheim is being used after the verb ist, not directly before a noun.
In German, adjectives usually take endings only when they come before a noun:
- der geheime Plan = the secret plan
But after sein and similar verbs, the adjective is in its basic form:
- Der Plan ist geheim.
So:
- geheime = before a noun
- geheim = after ist
Is geheim an adjective or an adverb here?
It is an adjective.
More specifically, it is a predicate adjective because it comes after the verb sein and describes the subject.
Compare:
- der geheime Plan → adjective before a noun
- Der Plan ist geheim. → predicate adjective after sein
It is not an adverb in this sentence.
Could I say Der geheime Plan instead?
Yes, but that is not a full sentence by itself in the same way.
- Der Plan ist geheim. = a complete sentence
- der geheime Plan = a noun phrase, meaning the secret plan
So they are related, but they do different jobs:
- one is a full statement
- the other is just a phrase
Can I leave out der and just say Plan ist geheim?
Normally, no. In standard German, singular countable nouns usually need a determiner such as an article.
So:
- Der Plan ist geheim. = normal
- Ein Plan ist geheim. = also possible, depending on meaning
- Plan ist geheim. = generally not standard in this context
German usually requires something like der, ein, dieser, etc. with a singular noun like Plan.
What is the difference between Der Plan ist geheim and Ein Plan ist geheim?
The difference is the article:
- Der Plan = the plan, a specific plan already known in the context
- Ein Plan = a plan, one plan among others, not specifically identified yet
So the grammar is the same, but the meaning changes depending on whether the noun is definite or indefinite.
Is this a normal way to say this in German?
Yes. It is a completely natural and standard sentence.
The pattern is very common:
- Das ist gut.
- Der Film ist interessant.
- Das Haus ist groß.
- Der Plan ist geheim.
It is a basic German sentence structure: subject + sein + adjective.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Der Plan ist geheim to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions