Breakdown of La même secrétaire envoie le dossier au comptable avant midi.
Questions & Answers about La même secrétaire envoie le dossier au comptable avant midi.
Why does même mean same here, and why is it placed before secrétaire?
In la même secrétaire, même means same.
So:
- la même secrétaire = the same secretary
In French, même usually comes before the noun when it means same:
- le même livre = the same book
- la même idée = the same idea
Be careful: même can also mean other things in different positions, such as even, but in this sentence it clearly means same.
Why is it la secrétaire? Is secrétaire feminine?
Here it is feminine because of the article la:
- la secrétaire = the female secretary
The noun secrétaire can refer to a man or a woman, and often the article tells you which one:
- le secrétaire = the male secretary
- la secrétaire = the female secretary
So the word itself does not change here, but the article does.
Why doesn’t même change to a special feminine form in la même secrétaire?
What form is envoie?
Envoie is the third-person singular present tense of envoyer:
- j’envoie = I send
- tu envoies = you send
- il / elle envoie = he / she sends
- nous envoyons = we send
- vous envoyez = you send
- ils / elles envoient = they send
In the sentence, the subject is la même secrétaire, which is singular, so French uses envoie.
Why is it le dossier? Does dossier mean exactly file?
Le dossier is the direct object of the verb:
- envoie quoi ? → le dossier
So:
- le dossier = the file / the folder / the case file / the document set
The exact English word depends on context. In office French, dossier often means a file, folder, or case file rather than just one single sheet of paper.
The article le is there because French usually uses an article where English might or might not use one.
Why is it au comptable instead of à le comptable?
What is the job of comptable? Is it the same as accountant?
Usually, yes.
- comptable = accountant / bookkeeper / accounting officer
The exact translation depends on the workplace. In many learning contexts, accountant is the safest translation.
Also note:
- le comptable = the male accountant
- la comptable = the female accountant
In your sentence, au comptable means to the accountant.
Why is there no article in avant midi?
French often uses time expressions without an article in set phrases like this.
- avant midi = before noon
- après midi is not used in the same way here; après-midi is a noun meaning afternoon
So avant midi is just the normal expression for before noon / before midday.
You do not say avant le midi in this meaning.
Is the word order basically the same as in English?
Yes, very similar.
The sentence is built like this:
- La même secrétaire = subject
- envoie = verb
- le dossier = direct object
- au comptable = indirect object / recipient
- avant midi = time expression
So the structure is:
Subject + Verb + Thing sent + Recipient + Time
That is close to English:
- The same secretary sends the file to the accountant before noon.
Could French also say envoie au comptable le dossier?
It is possible in some contexts, but La même secrétaire envoie le dossier au comptable avant midi is the most neutral and natural order.
French usually puts the direct object right after the verb here:
- envoie le dossier au comptable
Moving au comptable earlier can sound more marked or stylistic, depending on the context.
For a learner, the safest default order is:
subject + verb + direct object + indirect object/complement
How is envoie pronounced, and are there any silent letters in the sentence?
Yes, several final letters are silent.
A rough pronunciation guide:
- La → la
- même → mem
- secrétaire → roughly seh-kreh-tehr
- envoie → roughly ahn-vwah
- le → luh
- dossier → roughly doh-syay
- au → oh
- comptable → roughly kohn-tab-luh or kohn-tabl
- avant midi → roughly ah-vahn mee-dee
A few useful notes:
- In même, the final e is not pronounced.
- In envoie, the ending is pronounced like -voie in voix-type sounds: vwah.
- In dossier, the -er ending sounds like ay.
- In avant, the final t is normally silent.
Why doesn’t French use a possessive like her file or his accountant here?
Because the sentence is simply stating the action in a neutral way:
- the same secretary sends the file to the accountant before noon
French often prefers ordinary definite articles such as le, la, and les when the context already makes the meaning clear.
So:
- le dossier does not have to mean a random file; it can mean the file already understood in context
- au comptable means to the accountant already known in the situation
French uses possessives less often than English in many everyday contexts.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from La même secrétaire envoie le dossier au comptable avant midi to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions