Question 1

Which tense is choisit in? It looks identical to the passé simple form.

Accepted Answer

choisit is the third-person singular of choisir in the present indicative (Marie chooses). Although the passé simple of choisir is also spelled choisit, the presence of trouve (also in the present) makes it clear we’re talking about present-tense narration.

Question 2

Why do I see parce qu’elle with an apostrophe? Shouldn’t it be parce que elle?

Accepted Answer

In French you drop (elide) the final e of que before a word that begins with a vowel or a mute h. To avoid the “ee e” clash you write parce que + elle as parce qu’elle, using the apostrophe to show the missing e.

Question 3

What does the pronoun le refer to in elle le trouve élégant? And why is it needed?

Accepted Answer

The pronoun le replaces un pantalon noir (masculine singular) to avoid repeating the noun. Grammatically you could say elle trouve le pantalon élégant, but using le is more natural: elle le trouve élégant = “she finds it elegant.”

Question 4

Why is the object pronoun le placed before the verb trouve instead of after?

Accepted Answer

In simple tenses (present, passé composé, etc.), French direct object pronouns come before the conjugated verb. Hence elle le trouve. The only time you put it after is in the affirmative imperative (e.g. trouve-le !).

Question 5

Why is noir not noire?

Accepted Answer

Noir agrees with pantalon, which is a masculine singular noun. The feminine form would be noire, but since pantalon is masculine, the color adjective remains noir.

Question 6

Similarly, why is élégant not élégante?

Accepted Answer

The same agreement rule applies: élégant modifies pantalon (masculine singular), so you use the masculine form élégant rather than élégante.

Question 7

Why is the color adjective noir placed after pantalon? In English, we say “black pants,” with the color before the noun.

Accepted Answer

Most French adjectives, especially colors, typically follow the noun: un pantalon noir. Only a small set of adjectives (Beauty, Age, Goodness, Size) usually come before the noun; colors are not in that group.

Question 8

Could I use car instead of parce que here? What’s the difference?

Accepted Answer

Yes: Marie choisit un pantalon noir, car elle le trouve élégant is correct. Car is a bit more formal or literary, while parce que is more common in everyday speech and can be shortened to parce qu’ before a vowel.

Question 9

Is it necessary to repeat elle in parce qu’elle? Could I drop the subject pronoun there?

Accepted Answer

No, you cannot drop the subject pronoun in French. Every finite verb must have an explicit subject (noun or pronoun). So you need elle in the subordinate clause: parce qu’elle.

Question 10

Why isn’t lui used as the pronoun instead of le?

Accepted Answer

Lui is an indirect object pronoun used with verbs that take à before their object. Trouver takes a direct object (you find something), so you use the direct object pronoun le (for masculine singular), not lui.

Marie choisit un pantalon noir parce qu'elle le trouve élégant.

Breakdown of Marie choisit un pantalon noir parce qu'elle le trouve élégant.

Questions & Answers about Marie choisit un pantalon noir parce qu'elle le trouve élégant.

Master French — from Marie choisit un pantalon noir parce qu'elle le trouve élégant to fluency