Breakdown of Paul était pauvre autrefois, mais il ne veut plus en parler.
être
to be
Paul
Paul
il
he
vouloir
to want
mais
but
parler
to talk
en
it
ne ... plus
no longer
pauvre
poor
autrefois
in the past
Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching French grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about Paul était pauvre autrefois, mais il ne veut plus en parler.
What does the adverb autrefois mean in this context?
Autrefois means in the past or formerly. It shows that Paul's state of being poor refers to an earlier time in his life rather than his current situation.
Why is the imperfect tense used in Paul était pauvre autrefois, and what does it imply?
The imperfect tense, as seen in était, is used to describe ongoing or habitual states in the past. It implies that Paul’s poverty was not a one-time event but a sustained condition during that period.
What do ne...plus express in the phrase mais il ne veut plus en parler?
The structure ne...plus translates to no longer or not anymore. It indicates that although Paul might have spoken about his situation before, he currently refuses to do so.
What is the function of the pronoun en in en parler?
In French, en is used to replace a prepositional phrase that begins with de (as in parler de quelque chose, meaning to talk about something). Here, en specifically refers to the subject of his past poverty, so it avoids repeating that idea.
Why is there a shift from the past tense in the first clause to the present tense in the second clause?
The shift in tenses reflects the timeline of the narrative. The first clause uses the imperfect tense to describe a past state (Paul's poverty), while the present tense in the second clause shows his current attitude—he now refuses to discuss that past situation.
What is the role of the conjunction mais in this sentence?
The conjunction mais serves to introduce a contrast. It contrasts Paul's former condition (being poor) with his present decision not to talk about it, highlighting a change in his life or perspective.