Breakdown of Li pli bone iras, ekde kiam ŝi komencis masaĝi lian kokson.
Questions & Answers about Li pli bone iras, ekde kiam ŝi komencis masaĝi lian kokson.
Why is it pli bone iras instead of just iras pli bone?
Both are possible. Esperanto word order is fairly flexible, and pli bone iras puts a little more focus on better.
- Li iras pli bone = He walks/goes better.
- Li pli bone iras = He walks/goes better, with better slightly emphasized.
A learner will probably hear Li iras pli bone more often because it feels more neutral.
What does iras mean here? Is it goes or walks?
Literally, iras means goes. But in context, it can naturally mean walks or gets around.
Because the sentence mentions massaging his hip, Li pli bone iras most likely means:
- he walks better
- he is moving around better
So this is a good example of Esperanto using a general verb where English might prefer a more specific one.
Why is it pli bone and not pli bona?
Because bone is an adverb, and it modifies the verb iras.
- bona = good, as an adjective
- bone = well, as an adverb
Here we are describing how he goes/walks, so we need the adverb:
- Li iras bone = He walks/goes well.
- Li iras pli bone = He walks/goes better.
If you used bona, it would need to describe a noun, not the verb.
What exactly does ekde kiam mean?
Ekde kiam means since or more literally starting from the time when.
Breakdown:
- ekde = since, from
- kiam = when
So:
- ekde kiam ŝi komencis masaĝi lian kokson = since she began massaging his hip
It marks the starting point of a situation that continues up to now.
Could this sentence also use de kiam instead of ekde kiam?
Yes, many speakers would also say de kiam.
- de kiam = since
- ekde kiam = since, emphasizing the starting point a bit more
So both are understandable:
- Li pli bone iras, de kiam ŝi komencis masaĝi lian kokson.
- Li pli bone iras, ekde kiam ŝi komencis masaĝi lian kokson.
Ekde can feel slightly more explicit about from that point onward.
Why is it komencis masaĝi instead of something like ekmasaĝis?
Komencis masaĝi means began to massage.
This is a very common Esperanto structure:
- komenci + infinitive
- ŝi komencis masaĝi = she began to massage
You could also form a verb with ek-:
- ŝi ekmasaĝis lian kokson = she started massaging his hip
Both are possible, but komencis masaĝi is very straightforward and often easier for learners to understand.
Why is it lian kokson with -n?
Because lian kokson is the direct object of masaĝi.
- li = he
- lia = his
- lian = his, accusative form because it belongs to a direct object
- kokso = hip
- kokson = hip, direct object
So:
- masaĝi lian kokson = to massage his hip
In Esperanto, when a noun takes -n as a direct object, any adjective or correlating word with it also agrees. Here lia becomes lian.
What does kokso mean exactly?
Kokso usually means hip.
Depending on context, English might translate it as:
- hip
- hip joint
- side of the pelvis
In this sentence, his hip is the most natural translation.
Why is the first verb in the present tense: iras?
Because the sentence describes a present result:
- Li pli bone iras = He walks better now / He is walking better now
Then the second part gives the starting point:
- ekde kiam ŝi komencis... = since she began...
So the pattern is:
- present situation now
- past event that started the change
This is very similar to English:
- He walks better since she began massaging his hip is awkward in English
- more natural English would be He has been walking better since she began massaging his hip
Esperanto often uses the simple present in places where English may prefer a present perfect construction.
Why is it komencis and not komencas?
Because the beginning happened in the past.
- ŝi komencis masaĝi = she began to massage
- ŝi komencas masaĝi = she is beginning to massage / begins to massage
The sentence says his improved walking started from that earlier point, so komencis is the correct tense.
Is ŝi komencis masaĝi lian kokson necessarily a one-time action?
No. It means she began massaging his hip, but it does not by itself say whether she did it once or repeatedly.
It simply marks the start of that action or practice. The context may suggest repeated treatment, but the grammar alone does not force that meaning.
Could masaĝi also be translated as to give a massage to?
Yes, depending on context.
- masaĝi lian kokson literally = to massage his hip
In natural English, you might say:
- massage his hip
- work on his hip
- give his hip a massage
But the Esperanto verb itself is just the straightforward to massage.
Why is lia changed to lian, but ŝi stays the same?
Because ŝi is the subject of komencis, while lian kokson is the object of masaĝi.
- ŝi komencis = she began
- ŝi is the subject, so no -n
- masaĝi lian kokson = to massage his hip
- kokson is the direct object, so it gets -n
- lian agrees with kokson, so it also gets -n
This is a very common feature of Esperanto agreement.
Could the sentence be understood as He is doing better rather than specifically He walks better?
Not usually from this sentence alone. Iras strongly suggests movement, going, or walking.
If you wanted He is doing better in a more general sense, Esperanto would probably use a different expression, such as something built around:
- farti = to fare, to be doing
- senti sin = to feel
So here the most natural understanding is specifically about his walking or mobility.
Is the comma necessary before ekde kiam?
It is normal and helpful. The comma separates the main clause from the time clause:
- Li pli bone iras, ekde kiam ŝi komencis masaĝi lian kokson.
Esperanto punctuation is not always identical to English punctuation, but this comma is perfectly natural because it marks a clear break between the statement and the explanation of when it became true.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning EsperantoMaster Esperanto — from Li pli bone iras, ekde kiam ŝi komencis masaĝi lian kokson to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions