Breakdown of Ni faris buĝeton sen ke ni forgesis la imposton.
Questions & Answers about Ni faris buĝeton sen ke ni forgesis la imposton.
What does sen ke mean here?
Sen ke means without followed by a whole clause.
So:
- sen = without
- ke = introduces a subordinate clause, roughly that
In this sentence, sen ke ni forgesis la imposton means something like without our forgetting the tax.
A shorter and often more natural Esperanto version is:
- Ni faris buĝeton sen forgesi la imposton.
That uses sen + infinitive instead of sen ke + full clause.
Is this sentence grammatical, and is it natural Esperanto?
It is understandable, but many speakers would probably prefer a simpler version:
- Ni faris buĝeton sen forgesi la imposton.
Why?
Because the subject is the same in both parts: ni in ni faris and ni forgesis. When the subject stays the same, Esperanto often prefers the shorter infinitive construction.
So:
- understandable: Ni faris buĝeton sen ke ni forgesis la imposton.
- more natural for many speakers: Ni faris buĝeton sen forgesi la imposton.
The sen ke version is especially useful when you want or need a full clause, for example if the subject is different.
Why is ni repeated?
Because after sen ke, you have a full subordinate clause, and a full clause normally needs its own subject and verb.
So in:
- sen ke ni forgesis la imposton
the clause has:
- subject: ni
- verb: forgesis
English often lets us avoid repeating the subject with without forgetting, but Esperanto only avoids the repetition if you switch to the infinitive version:
- sen forgesi la imposton
So:
- sen ke ni forgesis... = full clause, subject repeated
- sen forgesi... = no separate subject stated
Do I need ne after sen ke?
No.
Sen already carries the idea of absence or negation, so you do not normally add ne for this meaning.
Correct idea:
- sen ke ni forgesis la imposton = without our forgetting the tax
If you said:
- sen ke ni ne forgesis la imposton
that would literally mean something like without our not forgetting the tax, which is not the intended meaning.
So for English speakers, the key point is:
- English: without forgetting
- Esperanto: sen forgesi / sen ke ...
- not: sen ke ... ne ... for this meaning
Why do buĝeton and imposton end in -n?
Because they are direct objects.
In Esperanto, the direct object usually takes -n.
Here:
- faris buĝeton = made a budget
- buĝeton is what was made
- forgesis la imposton = forgot the tax
- imposton is what was forgotten
So the -n ending shows what receives the action.
This is one of the most important patterns in Esperanto syntax.
Why is it la imposton and not just imposton?
La marks the noun as definite: the tax rather than just a tax or tax in general.
In context, this suggests a specific tax that the speakers already have in mind, probably one that belongs in the budget.
So:
- imposton = a tax / tax
- la imposton = the tax, a specific one
Whether la is needed depends on context. If the tax is already known or understood, la is natural.
Why is the verb forgesis in the past tense?
Because the whole sentence is describing a past situation.
- Ni faris = we made
- ni forgesis = we forgot
Even though the clause is inside sen ke, it is still a clause with its own verb, and that verb gets a tense.
That said, learners should know two things:
- the sentence as written is understandable
- many speakers would avoid this issue by saying sen forgesi la imposton
You may also encounter sen ke with other verb forms depending on nuance, but for everyday learning, the safest takeaway is:
- full clause: sen ke
- subject + finite verb
- simpler same-subject version: sen
- infinitive
Could I say sen forgesi la imposton instead?
Yes — and for many speakers, that is the best version here.
So this is very natural:
- Ni faris buĝeton sen forgesi la imposton.
It is shorter and smoother because the subject is still ni.
A useful rule of thumb:
- same subject in both parts -> often use sen
- infinitive
- different subject, or if you want a full clause -> use sen ke
For example:
- Ni faris buĝeton sen forgesi la imposton.
- Ni faris buĝeton sen ke la librotenisto forgesu la imposton.
In the second one, the subject changes, so a full clause makes more sense.
How is buĝeton pronounced, especially ĝ?
The special letter here is ĝ.
- ĝ is pronounced like the g in gem, giant, or judge-like sounds, depending on accent
- buĝeto sounds roughly like boo-JEH-to
Breaking it up:
- bu = boo
- ĝe = like je in Jeff
- to = to
And buĝeton is just buĝeto plus the object ending -n.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning EsperantoMaster Esperanto — from Ni faris buĝeton sen ke ni forgesis la imposton to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions