Breakdown of Wij moeten dit plan goedkeuren voordat we beginnen.
Questions & Answers about Wij moeten dit plan goedkeuren voordat we beginnen.
Moeten is a modal verb expressing obligation (‘must/have to’). In Dutch, modals agree with the subject:
- ik moet
- jij/u moet
- hij/zij/het moet
- wij/jullie/zij moeten
Since our subject is wij, we use moeten.
Dutch uses verb clusters at the end when a modal verb is present. The rule is:
- Conjugate the modal (moeten) in second position.
- Place any objects (here dit plan) next.
- Put the infinitive (goedgekeuren) at the clause’s end.
So: “Wij (S) moeten (V) dit plan (O) goedkeuren (Inf).”
Voordat is a subordinating conjunction (‘before’). In Dutch subordinate clauses, the finite verb moves to final position. The order is:
- conjunction (voordat)
- subject (we)
- other elements
- finite verb (beginnen)
Yes. When a subordinate clause comes first, it’s placed before the main clause, followed by a comma. The main clause still obeys the V2 (verb-second) rule: the finite verb moeten is in second position. Result:
“Voordat we beginnen, moeten wij dit plan goedkeuren.”
- Voordat = before an action.
- Nadat = after an action.
To say “We must approve this plan after we start,” use:
“Wij moeten dit plan goedkeuren nadat we beginnen.”
(If you want to emphasize that starting is fully completed, you could say “nadat we zijn begonnen.”)
- Goedkeuren implies a formal or official approval (e.g., a committee must authorize a plan).
- Accepteren is more general acceptance (e.g., accept an invitation or an offer).
Both are understandable here, but goedkeuren stresses the authorization aspect.