Breakdown of Doktorice, možete li, molim vas, doći ranije?
moći
to be able to
doći
to come
molim vas
please
ranije
earlier
doktorica
doctor
Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching Croatian grammar and vocabulary.
Questions & Answers about Doktorice, možete li, molim vas, doći ranije?
Why is Doktorice used here, and what does the comma after it mean?
- Doktorice is the vocative (direct-address) form of the feminine noun doktorica (doctor). You use the vocative when you’re calling or addressing someone directly.
- The comma marks direct address: Doktorice, ... = “Doctor, ...”
- If the doctor were male, you’d say Doktore, ...
- In everyday speech some people use the nominative (Doktorica) for address, but the standard form is the vocative Doktorice.
- With a surname: Doktorice Horvat, možete li...
How polite/formal is this sentence?
- It’s polite and formal: it uses the formal second person plural (možete) and the politeness marker molim vas.
- This is appropriate for addressing a doctor or any professional.
What’s the difference between možete li, biste li mogli, and hoćete li?
- Možete li... literally asks about ability (can you), but it’s a standard way to make a polite request; neutral and common.
- Biste li mogli... (conditional) is softer and more tentative, often felt as more polite: Could you possibly...
- Hoćete li... focuses on willingness (will you); it can sound more direct depending on tone, but it’s also common.
Why does li come after možete? Can it go elsewhere?
- li is a clitic particle that turns a statement into a yes–no question and must stand in second position in the clause (after the first stressed word).
- Hence Možete li doći..., not Li možete...
- With the verb to be, you often see Je li...
- In standard Croatian, prefer ... li ... over Da li ... in writing. Da li is widely understood but is colloquial and more typical of Serbian.
Can I ask the question without li, just using intonation?
- Yes: Možete doći ranije? works in speech and informal writing with rising intonation.
- The ... li form is the safest, most neutral option in standard written Croatian.
Where can I put molim vas, and do I need commas?
- molim vas is optional and can go:
- At the start: Molim vas, možete li doći ranije?
- In the middle: Možete li, molim vas, doći ranije? (as in your sentence)
- At the end: Možete li doći ranije, molim vas?
- When it’s in the middle, set it off with commas because it’s a parenthetical politeness marker.
Should I capitalize Vas?
- In formal letters/emails to a specific person, it’s common to capitalize polite forms: Vi, Vam, Vas (e.g., Molim Vas).
- In ordinary text, lowercase (vas) is fine. Be consistent within the same message.
Why is doći used instead of dođete or da dođete?
- After modal verbs like moći, htjeti, trebati, morati, Croatian uses the bare infinitive: možete doći.
- Možete da dođete is characteristic of Serbian; in standard Croatian it’s avoided in careful writing.
- Možete dođete (present without da) is ungrammatical.
Could I use the imperative instead to make the request?
- Yes, but it’s stronger: Dođite ranije, molim vas. That’s a direct request/command, softened by molim vas.
- Možete li doći ranije? sounds more tentative and is usually safer with professionals.
Does the position of ranije matter? Is Možete li ranije doći also correct?
- Both Možete li doći ranije? and Možete li ranije doći? are correct.
- Word order is flexible; placing ranije earlier can lightly emphasize “earlier,” but there’s no big difference here.
Can I use prije instead of ranije?
- Use ranije (earlier) for “earlier than planned.”
- Prije typically needs a complement: prije pet (before five), prije nego (što) dođete (before you come).
- Doći ranije is natural; doći prije usually sounds incomplete unless you add what it’s before.
Is molim te possible here?
- Yes, but only with informal singular ti: Možeš li, molim te, doći ranije?
- Keep the register consistent. Avoid mixing (Možete li, molim te... / Možeš li, molim vas...).
How do I pronounce the special letters in this sentence?
- ž (in možete) sounds like the s in measure (zh).
- č (in doći) is a hard ch, as in chop.
- ć (also in doći) is a softer ch; many learners approximate both č/ć as ch at first.
- Vowels are all pronounced; there are no silent letters.
Are all the commas really necessary?
- Yes, in standard writing:
- Comma after Doktorice marks direct address.
- Commas around molim vas mark a parenthetical insertion.
- In quick messages you may see fewer commas, but the fully punctuated version is textbook-correct.
What does molim vas literally mean, and what case is vas?
- Literally: “I ask/beg you.” Molim = I ask/please; vas is the accusative of the polite vi (you).
- It has become a set phrase meaning “please.”
Could I use stići instead of doći?
- Yes: Možete li stići ranije? means “Can you arrive earlier?” It emphasizes arrival rather than the act of coming.
- With appointments, both doći and stići are acceptable; doći is a bit more neutral.