Breakdown of A l'abril acostumem a veure núvols sobre la muntanya, però al maig gairebé sempre fa sol.
Questions & Answers about A l'abril acostumem a veure núvols sobre la muntanya, però al maig gairebé sempre fa sol.
Why is it A l'abril but al maig?
Both mean in April / in May, but the form changes because of the noun that follows.
- a + el abril becomes a l'abril
- a + el maig becomes al maig
So:
- a l'abril = in April
- al maig = in May
This happens because abril begins with a vowel, so the article el contracts to l'. With maig, which begins with a consonant, a + el becomes al.
This is very common in Catalan:
- a l'estiu
- al gener
- a l'agost
Why is there an article before the months at all?
In Catalan, months often appear with the definite article, especially after prepositions like a.
So Catalan commonly says:
- a l'abril
- al maig
- al juny
This is different from English, where we just say in April or in May without an article.
You do not need to translate the article literally. It is just part of the normal Catalan structure.
Why is it acostumem a veure instead of just veiem?
Acostumem a veure means something like we usually tend to see or we are used to seeing.
It adds the idea of a habit or a typical pattern.
Compare:
- veiem núvols = we see clouds
- acostumem a veure núvols = we usually see clouds / we tend to see clouds
So acostumar helps express regularity or habit, not just a simple fact.
Why is there an a in acostumem a veure?
Because the verb acostumar is followed by a + infinitive when it means to usually do something.
Pattern:
- acostumar a + infinitive
Examples:
- Acostumo a llegir a la nit = I usually read at night
- Acostumem a veure núvols = We usually see clouds
So the a is required by the verb pattern.
Why is there no subject pronoun for we?
Catalan often leaves out subject pronouns because the verb ending already tells you who the subject is.
Here:
- acostumem = we usually
- the ending -em shows it is nosaltres = we
So:
- Acostumem a veure... already means
- We usually see...
You could say Nosaltres acostumem a veure..., but it is usually unnecessary unless you want emphasis or contrast.
What exactly is acostumem here?
Acostumem is the 1st person plural present tense of acostumar.
That means:
- infinitive: acostumar
- present: acostumo, acostumes, acostuma, acostumem, acostumeu, acostumen
In this sentence, acostumem means we usually / we tend to.
Why is it núvols without an article?
Because Catalan often omits the article when talking about things in a general, non-specific way, especially in plural.
Here, núvols means clouds in general, not specific clouds already known to the listener.
So:
- veure núvols = to see clouds
- veure els núvols = to see the clouds specifically
In this sentence, the general meaning is the natural one.
Why is it sobre la muntanya?
Sobre means over / above.
So núvols sobre la muntanya means the clouds are over the mountain.
This does not necessarily mean they are touching it or sitting on top of it. It just places them above it.
Learners sometimes compare:
- sobre la muntanya = over the mountain
- damunt de la muntanya = on top of / above the mountain
In many contexts, sobre works well for clouds because they are hovering above something.
What does gairebé sempre mean, and why is it in that position?
Gairebé sempre means almost always.
It comes before the verb phrase fa sol because it modifies how often that weather happens.
So:
- al maig gairebé sempre fa sol = in May it is almost always sunny
This position is very natural in Catalan.
You can think of the structure as:
- time
- frequency expression
- verb phrase
- frequency expression
Here:
- al maig = time
- gairebé sempre = frequency
- fa sol = verb phrase
Why does Catalan say fa sol instead of something more literal like there is sun?
Catalan uses fer in many weather expressions.
So:
- fa sol = it is sunny
- literally, something like it makes sun, but you should learn it as a fixed weather expression
Other common examples:
- fa fred = it is cold
- fa calor = it is hot
- fa vent = it is windy
- fa bon temps = the weather is nice
This is one of those places where Catalan and English organize weather differently.
Why is it fa and not a plural form?
Because fa sol is an impersonal weather expression.
The verb is always in the 3rd person singular:
- fa sol
- fa fred
- fa calor
There is no real subject like the sun doing the action in the grammar of the sentence. It works a bit like English it is sunny, where it does not refer to a specific thing.
Can I say en abril instead of a l'abril?
In standard Catalan, a l'abril and al maig are the normal choices in this kind of sentence.
Using en with months is not the standard pattern here.
So for a learner, it is best to use:
- a l'abril
- al maig
- al juny
That will sound natural and correct.
What is the role of però in the sentence?
Però means but.
It introduces a contrast between the two parts:
- in April we usually see clouds over the mountain
- but in May it is almost always sunny
So però connects two ideas that contrast with each other. It is used just like English but.
Could the sentence use veiem instead of a veure somehow?
Not in the same structure.
After acostumem, you need an infinitive:
- acostumem a veure ✅
You would not say:
- acostumem veiem ❌
- acostumem a veiem ❌
If you want to use veiem, you need a different sentence:
- A l'abril veiem núvols sobre la muntanya = In April we see clouds over the mountain
That is grammatical, but it loses the specific idea of habit or tendency carried by acostumem a veure.
Is fa sol a fixed expression I should memorize?
Yes. It is very useful to learn fa sol as a chunk.
Catalan weather expressions often work best when memorized as whole phrases:
- fa sol
- fa fred
- fa calor
- fa vent
- plou
- neva
That will help you sound more natural than trying to build them word by word from English.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from A l'abril acostumem a veure núvols sobre la muntanya, però al maig gairebé sempre fa sol to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions