Breakdown of La planta que és al costat de la finestra és de la meva mare.
Questions & Answers about La planta que és al costat de la finestra és de la meva mare.
Why is it la planta and not el planta?
Because planta is a feminine noun in Catalan, so it takes the feminine article la.
- la planta = the plant
- una planta = a plant
As in many Romance languages, the article has to agree with the noun’s gender.
What does que mean here?
Here que is a relative pronoun, meaning that or which.
So:
- La planta que és al costat de la finestra
= The plant that is next to the window
It links la planta to the extra information és al costat de la finestra.
Can que be omitted, like English sometimes omits that?
No, not here.
In English, you can sometimes drop that, but only in certain cases, such as The book that I bought → The book I bought.
In this Catalan sentence, que is the subject of the relative clause, so it must stay:
- la planta que és... = the plant that is...
You cannot leave it out.
Why does the sentence use és and not està for location?
Catalan often uses ser where English speakers might expect estar, especially when talking about where something is located.
So és al costat de la finestra is natural Catalan for is next to the window.
Very roughly:
- ser is commonly used for location in many normal descriptions
- estar is used more for states, conditions, or sometimes temporary/resulting situations
So this is not a direct match with Spanish or English patterns. In this sentence, és is fine and natural.
What does al costat de mean?
Al costat de means next to, beside, or at the side of.
Examples:
- al costat de la finestra = next to the window
- al costat de la porta = next to the door
It is a fixed expression you should learn as a whole.
Why is it al and not just a el?
Because al is the contraction of a + el.
- a + el → al
So:
- al costat literally comes from a el costat
This contraction is standard in Catalan, just like:
- del = de + el
Why does de la meva mare mean possession here?
In this sentence, és de la meva mare means belongs to my mother or is my mother’s.
Catalan often uses ser de + person to show ownership:
- És del Joan = It belongs to Joan
- És de la meva mare = It belongs to my mother
So de here expresses possession, not just of in a literal English sense.
Why is there an article in la meva mare? Why not just meva mare?
In standard Catalan, possessives usually go with the definite article:
- la meva mare = my mother
- el meu pare = my father
- el meu cotxe = my car
This is different from English, which does not use the before my.
So la meva mare is the normal standard pattern.
Why is it meva and not meu?
Because the possessive has to agree with the noun it describes.
Here the noun is mare, which is feminine singular, so the possessive must also be feminine singular:
- el meu pare = my father
- la meva mare = my mother
So:
- meu = masculine singular
- meva = feminine singular
How is the whole sentence structured?
It has two main parts:
- La planta que és al costat de la finestra
= The plant that is next to the window - és de la meva mare
= belongs to my mother / is my mother’s
So the structure is:
[noun] + [relative clause] + [main verb + possession]
That is why the sentence literally works like:
The plant that is next to the window belongs to my mother.
Can planta mean something else in Catalan?
Yes. Planta can mean plant, but in some contexts it can also mean floor/story of a building.
For example:
- Una planta verda = a green plant
- La tercera planta = the third floor
In your sentence, al costat de la finestra makes it clear that planta means plant.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from La planta que és al costat de la finestra és de la meva mare to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions