Breakdown of Les escombraries fan mala olor perquè encara són a la cuina.
Questions & Answers about Les escombraries fan mala olor perquè encara són a la cuina.
Why is les escombraries plural? In English, trash/garbage often feels singular.
In Catalan, escombraries is normally a plural noun, even when it refers to trash in general.
So Catalan says:
- Les escombraries són...
- Les escombraries fan...
not singular forms.
This is similar to how some English nouns are grammatically plural even when they refer to one general thing, like clothes or scissors.
So in this sentence, the plural verb fan matches les escombraries.
Why does the sentence use fan mala olor? Does it literally mean make bad smell?
Yes, literally fer mala olor is to make a bad smell, but in natural English we would usually translate it as to smell bad or to stink.
This is a very common Catalan structure:
- fer olor = to smell
- fer bona olor = to smell good
- fer mala olor = to smell bad
So:
- Les escombraries fan mala olor = The trash smells bad
This is one of those expressions that should be learned as a chunk.
Why is it mala olor and not mal olor?
Because olor is a feminine noun in Catalan.
So the adjective has to agree with it:
- bona olor
- mala olor
not bon olor or mal olor in standard agreement with this noun.
The pattern is:
- una olor
- l’olor
- mala olor
What does perquè mean here, and why does it have an accent?
Here perquè means because.
In Catalan, perquè with an accent and written as one word is commonly used for because:
- fan mala olor perquè encara són a la cuina
- they smell bad because they are still in the kitchen
This is important because Catalan also has similar-looking forms such as per què, which usually means why / for what in questions or certain structures.
So in this sentence:
- perquè = because
What does encara mean in this sentence?
Encara here means still.
So:
- encara són a la cuina = they are still in the kitchen
It tells you the situation has not changed yet.
Other examples:
- Encara dorm. = He/She is still sleeping.
- Encara no ha arribat. = He/She still hasn’t arrived.
In your sentence, encara explains why the trash smells bad: it has not yet been taken out.
Why does the sentence say són a la cuina and not estan a la cuina?
This is a very common question for English speakers.
In Catalan, ser is often used to say where something or someone is located:
- És a casa.
- Som a Barcelona.
- Les claus són a la taula.
So són a la cuina is perfectly normal Catalan for they are in the kitchen.
English speakers often expect estar because of Spanish, but Catalan does not always work the same way. In Catalan, ser is very common for location, especially in neutral statements about where something is.
You may also hear estar in some contexts or varieties, but són a la cuina is standard and natural.
Why is it a la cuina and not a contracted form like al cuina?
Because a + la does not contract in Catalan.
So:
- a + la = a la
- a + el = al
That means:
- a la cuina = in/to the kitchen
- al menjador = in/to the dining room
So a la cuina is exactly what we expect, because cuina is feminine: la cuina.
Do we need the article les before escombraries?
Usually yes. Catalan uses definite articles more often than English does.
So Catalan normally says:
- Les escombraries
- La cuina
where English might simply say:
- trash
- kitchen
In this sentence, les escombraries refers to the trash / the garbage, and using the article sounds natural and standard.
How is escombraries pronounced?
A helpful approximate pronunciation is:
əs-kom-brə-REE-əs
More carefully in Central Catalan, it is roughly:
[əz.kum.brəˈɾi.əs]
A few pronunciation notes:
- The first e is usually a weak uh sound.
- The stress falls on ri: escombra-RI-es
- The r in -ries is a tapped Catalan r, somewhat like the quick Spanish single r
If you just remember escombra-RI-es, with the stress near the end, that will already help a lot.
Could I say Les escombraries tenen mala olor instead?
You might be understood, but fan mala olor is the much more natural expression.
Catalan usually prefers:
- fer olor
- fer bona olor
- fer mala olor
rather than tenir mala olor in everyday usage for this meaning.
So if you want to sound natural, learn:
- Això fa mala olor.
- Les escombraries fan mala olor.
What is the basic structure of the whole sentence?
The sentence has two parts:
Les escombraries fan mala olor
= the main clauseperquè encara són a la cuina
= the reason clause introduced by perquè (because)
So the pattern is:
[statement] + perquè + [reason]
In this case:
- Les escombraries fan mala olor = what is happening
- perquè encara són a la cuina = why it is happening
This is a very useful sentence pattern to reuse in Catalan.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Les escombraries fan mala olor perquè encara són a la cuina to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions