Breakdown of Jo voldria el got més ple i la sopa menys salada.
Questions & Answers about Jo voldria el got més ple i la sopa menys salada.
Why is jo included? I thought Catalan often drops subject pronouns.
Yes, Catalan often drops subject pronouns because the verb ending already shows the person. So Voldria el got més ple... is also correct.
Here, jo is included for emphasis, clarity, or politeness of tone. It can sound a bit more personal, like As for me, I’d like... It is not required, but it is perfectly natural.
Why is voldria used instead of vull?
Voldria is the conditional form of voler and is a common polite way to make a request, like I would like in English.
- Vull = I want
- Voldria = I would like
In a restaurant or similar situation, voldria sounds softer and more courteous than vull.
Why are there definite articles: el got and la sopa? Why not just say the nouns by themselves?
In Catalan, definite articles are used more often than in English. In a context like ordering food or commenting on what has been served, el got and la sopa sound natural because they refer to specific things: the glass and the soup in front of you.
So Catalan often says:
- el got
- la sopa
where English might simply say the glass / the soup, or sometimes phrase the idea differently.
Why is it més ple and menys salada? How do més and menys work here?
Més means more and menys means less. They go before the adjective they modify.
So:
- més ple = more full / fuller
- menys salada = less salty
This is the normal Catalan way to make comparisons with adjectives:
- més alt = taller
- menys car = less expensive
Catalan usually forms these comparisons analytically with més and menys, rather than with endings like English -er.
Why is it ple with got, but salada with sopa?
Because adjectives in Catalan usually agree in gender and number with the noun they describe.
- got is masculine singular, so the adjective is ple
- sopa is feminine singular, so the adjective is salada
Compare:
- el got ple
- la tassa plena
- la sopa salada
- els gots plens
Agreement is very important in Catalan.
Why do the adjectives come after the nouns: el got més ple, la sopa menys salada?
Because in Catalan, descriptive adjectives normally come after the noun.
So:
- el got ple
- la sopa salada
And when you add més or menys, the whole adjective phrase still stays after the noun:
- el got més ple
- la sopa menys salada
This is more natural in Catalan than putting the adjective before the noun.
Is més ple really natural? In English, more full can sound awkward.
Yes, it is natural in Catalan. Ple means full, and més ple is a normal way to say fuller or more full.
Catalan does not avoid this structure the way English sometimes does. So el got més ple is a normal and understandable way to ask for the glass to be filled more.
Why isn’t voldria repeated before la sopa?
Because one instance of voldria can govern both parts of the sentence.
So:
- Jo voldria el got més ple i la sopa menys salada
means:
- I would like the glass fuller and the soup less salty
Repeating the verb is possible for extra emphasis, but it is not necessary:
- Jo voldria el got més ple i voldria la sopa menys salada
The version without repetition sounds smoother and more natural here.
Does ple describe the glass itself or what is inside it?
Grammatically, ple agrees with got, so it describes the glass. But semantically, the idea is that the glass should contain more of whatever is being served.
This is normal in Catalan, just as English can say a full glass even though what is really full is the glass’s contents. So el got més ple means the glass should be filled more.
Could I change the order and say la sopa menys salada i el got més ple?
Yes. The order can be changed if the context allows it:
- Jo voldria la sopa menys salada i el got més ple.
That would still be correct. The original order may simply reflect what the speaker wants to mention first. In Catalan, changing the order often changes emphasis more than meaning.
Would this sentence still be grammatical without jo?
Yes:
- Voldria el got més ple i la sopa menys salada.
This is fully grammatical and probably even more common in everyday Catalan. Adding jo just gives a bit more explicitness or emphasis.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Jo voldria el got més ple i la sopa menys salada to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions