Breakdown of Li vaig dir que aquella joguina gairebé sempre era a la meva bossa quan jo era petita.
Questions & Answers about Li vaig dir que aquella joguina gairebé sempre era a la meva bossa quan jo era petita.
What does li mean here?
Li is an indirect object pronoun. Here it means to him, to her, or to you (formal singular).
So:
Li vaig dir = I told him/her/you
Catalan often uses these short pronouns before the verb. By itself, li does not tell you whether the person is male or female; the context does that.
Does vaig dir literally mean I went to say?
No. In modern Catalan, vaig + infinitive is a very common past tense called the periphrastic past.
So:
- dic = I say
- vaig dir = I said / I told
- he dit = I have said
Even though vaig originally comes from anar (to go), in this structure it does not mean movement. Vaig dir just means I said / I told.
Why is que used after dir?
Que introduces the next clause, like English that.
So:
- Li vaig dir que... = I told him/her that...
In English, that is often omitted: I told her the toy was...
In Catalan, que is usually kept.
Why is it aquella joguina and not aquesta joguina?
Because aquella means that, while aquesta means this.
Catalan makes a distinction like this:
- aquesta joguina = this toy
- aquella joguina = that toy
Also, aquella has to agree with joguina, which is feminine singular, so you get:
- aquell for masculine singular
- aquella for feminine singular
What does gairebé sempre mean?
Gairebé means almost, and sempre means always.
Together:
gairebé sempre = almost always
It is placed before era because it modifies the idea of was:
aquella joguina gairebé sempre era a la meva bossa
= that toy was almost always in my bag
Why is it era and not va ser?
Era is the imperfect of ser, and the imperfect is used for:
- repeated or habitual actions in the past
- background description
- ongoing past situations
Here, gairebé sempre strongly suggests a habit or repeated pattern, so era is the natural choice:
- era a la meva bossa = it was / used to be in my bag
If you said va ser, it would sound more like one completed occasion.
Why is it era and not estava?
This is a very common question for English speakers, especially if they also know Spanish.
In Catalan, ser is often used for simple location, especially in neutral statements about where something is:
- On és la joguina? És a la bossa.
= Where is the toy? It is in the bag.
So era a la meva bossa is perfectly normal.
Estar can also appear in some contexts or varieties, often with a slightly stronger sense of temporary state or placement, but ser is very natural here.
Why does Catalan use a la meva bossa for in my bag?
Catalan often uses a where English would use in or at.
So:
- era a la meva bossa = it was in my bag
If you want to stress the idea of being physically inside, Catalan can also say:
- dins de la meva bossa
- dintre de la meva bossa
But a la meva bossa is a normal everyday way to say it.
Why is it la meva bossa and not just meva bossa?
Because Catalan normally uses the definite article with possessives.
So:
- la meva bossa = my bag
- el meu llibre = my book
- les meves claus = my keys
This is different from English, where you normally just say my bag without the.
Why does it say quan jo era petita? Is jo necessary, and why is petita feminine?
Jo is optional here. Catalan often leaves subject pronouns out because the verb already shows the person:
- quan era petita = when I was little
- quan jo era petita = same meaning, but with extra emphasis or clarity
Petita is feminine singular, so it tells you the speaker is female. A male speaker would say:
- quan jo era petit
So this part means when I was little, with the adjective agreeing with the speaker.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Li vaig dir que aquella joguina gairebé sempre era a la meva bossa quan jo era petita to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions