Breakdown of A la meva germana li fan mal les dents, i demà anirà al dentista.
Questions & Answers about A la meva germana li fan mal les dents, i demà anirà al dentista.
Yes, they refer to the same person, but this is normal in Catalan.
This is called clitic doubling:
- a la meva germana = the full indirect object phrase
- li = the indirect object pronoun (to her)
In Catalan, when the indirect object is stated explicitly, especially at the beginning of the sentence, the pronoun is usually still kept:
- A la meva germana li fan mal les dents.
This sounds natural. By contrast, leaving out li here would sound awkward or wrong to many speakers.
You can also say just:
- Li fan mal les dents.
if it is already clear who li refers to.
In Catalan, with fer mal, the thing that hurts is treated as the subject.
So in:
- A la meva germana li fan mal les dents
the subject is les dents (the teeth), and that is why the verb is plural:
- fan = they do / they hurt
Literally, the structure is closer to:
- The teeth hurt her than to
- My sister hurts
This is very common in Catalan:
- Em fa mal el cap = My head hurts / My head is hurting
- Em fan mal els peus = My feet hurt