Breakdown of Si no tens la resposta, fes una pregunta.
Questions & Answers about Si no tens la resposta, fes una pregunta.
Why does the sentence start with si?
Si means if. It introduces a condition:
- Si no tens la resposta = If you don’t have the answer
- fes una pregunta = ask a question
So the whole sentence follows the common pattern if X, do Y.
Why is it no tens and not something else?
Tens is the 2nd person singular form of tenir (to have) in the present tense.
- jo tinc = I have
- tu tens = you have
- ell/ella té = he/she has
So no tens means you don’t have.
Catalan usually forms negation by putting no before the verb:
- tens = you have
- no tens = you don’t have
Why is it la resposta and not just resposta?
La resposta means the answer.
Catalan often uses the definite article where English also does:
- la resposta = the answer
- una pregunta = a question
Here, la resposta refers to a specific answer, while una pregunta means any question.
Why is the second verb fes? What verb is that?
Fes is the tu imperative form of fer, which usually means to do or to make. In Catalan, fer una pregunta is the normal way to say to ask a question.
So:
- fer una pregunta = to ask a question
- fes una pregunta = ask a question
This is a command or instruction directed to one person.
Is fes an irregular form?
Yes. It comes from the irregular verb fer.
Some useful forms are:
- fer = to do / to make
- fa = he/she does
- fem = we do
- fes = do! / make! / ask! (to one person)
So fes is not built in a fully regular way. It is a form you should memorize.
Why does Catalan use fer una pregunta instead of a verb meaning ask?
Catalan often uses fer in expressions where English uses a more specific verb. One very common expression is:
- fer una pregunta = to ask a question
This is completely natural Catalan. English speakers may expect a direct equivalent of ask, but here Catalan uses the expression with fer.
Why is there a comma in the sentence?
The comma separates the conditional clause from the main instruction:
- Si no tens la resposta, = If you don’t have the answer,
- fes una pregunta. = ask a question.
This is very similar to English punctuation in a sentence like:
- If you don’t know the answer, ask a question.
Is this sentence informal or formal?
It is informal singular, because it uses:
- tens = you have (tu form)
- fes = do/ask! (tu imperative)
If you wanted a more formal version, you would use the vostè form instead.
How would this sentence change for you all or you plural?
For vosaltres (informal plural), it would be:
- Si no teniu la resposta, feu una pregunta.
Changes:
- teniu = you all have
- feu = do/make/ask! (plural imperative of fer)
Can the sentence also mean make a question?
No. Even though fer often means make or do, in fer una pregunta the natural translation is ask a question.
So you should understand:
- fes una pregunta = ask a question
not literally make a question in normal English.
Why is una pregunta indefinite?
Una pregunta means a question, not the question. The idea is not about one specific question already known to both people. It means:
- ask some question
- ask a question if you need to
That is why the indefinite article una is used.
What is the basic word order of the sentence?
The structure is:
- Si
- negative clause + comma + imperative clause
More specifically:
- Si = if
- no tens la resposta = you don’t have the answer
- fes una pregunta = ask a question
This word order is very natural in Catalan and closely matches English:
- If you don’t have the answer, ask a question.
More from this lesson
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CatalanMaster Catalan — from Si no tens la resposta, fes una pregunta to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions