Breakdown of Es liegen Bälle in der Manege.
es
it
in
in
liegen
to lie
der Ball
the ball
die Manege
the circus ring
Questions & Answers about Es liegen Bälle in der Manege.
Why does the sentence use the plural verb liegen when it starts with Es?
In this sentence, Es is just a dummy placeholder filling the first position. The actual subject of the sentence is Bälle (balls). Because Bälle is plural, the verb must also be the plural liegen.
Could I just say Bälle liegen in der Manege?
Yes, absolutely! If you move the real subject (Bälle) to the first position, the dummy es disappears entirely. German speakers use this dummy es to delay the subject, usually to set a scene or introduce new information into a story.
How is Es liegen different from using Es gibt?
Es gibt simply expresses existence, meaning "there are balls." Using Es liegen is more descriptive. It tells you exactly how the balls are positioned: they are physically resting on the ground.
Why is it in der Manege instead of in die Manege?
The word in is a two-way preposition. Because the sentence describes a stationary location (where the balls currently are) rather than movement toward a destination, it requires the dative case. The feminine noun die Manege changes to der Manege in the dative case.
Learn Es liegen Bälle in der Manege and more in German
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free