Breakdown of Miten voimme edistää opiskelua, jos vain rankaisemme?
vain
only
voida
can, to be able to
jos
if
miten
how (in what way)
Questions & Answers about Miten voimme edistää opiskelua, jos vain rankaisemme?
Why does the verb edistää take the partitive object opiskelua instead of an accusative object?
The verb edistää (to promote, advance) expresses an ongoing or continuous action, rather than an action that brings a process to a final, completed result. Verbs of this nature (often called irresultative verbs) typically require their object to be in the partitive case.
Could I use the verb opiskella instead of the noun opiskelua here?
No, because edistää requires a noun as its object, not an infinitive verb. You have to turn the action into a noun first. The suffix -u or -y is frequently used to turn a verb into a noun, so opiskella becomes the noun opiskelu (the act of studying), which then takes the partitive ending.
What is the basic form of rankaisemme, and how is it conjugated?
The basic form is rankaista (to punish), which belongs to Verb Type 3. To conjugate it, you remove the infinitive marker -ta to get the consonant stem rankais-, add the linking vowel -e-, and finally attach the personal ending -mme.
Why is the word vain placed right before the verb in the second clause?
Vain (only, just) generally precedes the exact word it modifies. Placing it right before rankaisemme emphasizes that punishing is the sole action being taken, contrasting heavily with the goal of promoting study.