When reviewing proposals or competition entries on a paneel (panel), speakers soften criticism with diplomatic routines. These routines acknowledge merit, pinpoint areas for improvement and frame advice as polite questions.
Assessing entries and describing feedback
- Review vocabulary:
- paneel (panel), beoordeel (assess, judge), inskrywing (entry, submission) and uitleg (layout).
- Possession is marked with se after the noun phrase: Hierdie inskrywing se uitleg (This entry's layout).
- toeganklik (accessible) pairs with vir to name who can use a space: vir almal toeganklik (accessible to everyone).
- egter means however. In the emphatic negation glad nie … nie (not … at all), the closing nie stands at the end of the clause: Die boonste verdieping is egter glad nie toeganklik nie.
- terugvoer means feedback, and kritiek op means criticism of.
- Adjective inflection (konstruktief and taktvol):
- After a linking verb such as is, adjectives stay uninflected: Sy kritiek op die ontwerp is konstruktief en baie taktvol.
- Before a noun, both take -e with standard spelling shifts.
- Final -f becomes -w-: konstruktief → konstruktiewe (constructive).
- A single consonant after a short vowel doubles: taktvol → taktvolle (tactful).
- Together: konstruktiewe en taktvolle terugvoer.
| Our panel is assessing every entry for the new library today. | Ons paneel beoordeel vandag elke inskrywing vir die nuwe biblioteek. |
| This entry's layout looks quite modern. | Hierdie inskrywing se uitleg lyk nogal modern. |
| The top floor, however, is not accessible at all. | Die boonste verdieping is egter glad nie toeganklik nie. |
| A public library must be accessible to everyone. | 'n Openbare biblioteek moet vir almal toeganklik wees. |
| The panel always gives constructive and tactful feedback. | Die paneel gee altyd konstruktiewe en taktvolle terugvoer. |
| His criticism of the design is constructive and very tactful. | Sy kritiek op die ontwerp is konstruktief en baie taktvol. |
Acknowledging value and pointing out weaknesses
- Daar is beslis meriete in …, maar … (There is certainly merit in …, but …):
- Cushions an objection by first acknowledging the value of a voorstel (proposal) or idee (idea).
- maar (but) is a coordinating conjunction, so it does not trigger inversion.
- The clause after maar keeps normal word order, with the subject before the verb: … maar dit is te duur, … maar die saal lyk klein.
- Daar is nog ruimte vir verbetering wat … betref (There is still room for improvement as far as … is concerned):
- ruimte vir verbetering (room for improvement) flags a weak spot diplomatically.
- The frame wat … betref (as far as … is concerned, regarding …) wraps around the aspect being evaluated, such as die uitleg (the layout) or die beligting (the lighting).
- The verb betref comes at the end of the clause.
| There is certainly merit in the proposal, but it is too expensive. | Daar is beslis meriete in die voorstel, maar dit is te duur. |
| There is certainly merit in her idea, but the hall looks small. | Daar is beslis meriete in haar idee, maar die saal lyk klein. |
| There is still room for improvement as far as the layout is concerned. | Daar is nog ruimte vir verbetering wat die uitleg betref. |
| There is still room for improvement as far as the lighting is concerned. | Daar is nog ruimte vir verbetering wat die beligting betref. |
Tactful suggestions and softening blunt criticism
- Sou dit nie beter wees om … te … nie? (Would it not be better to …?):
- Uses sou (would) in a negative question to turn a recommendation into a polite suggestion.
- The suggested action sits in an om … te
- infinitive clause: om die ingang te skuif (to move the entrance), om groter vensters te kies (to choose larger windows).
- Negation: the closing nie goes at the very end of the whole sentence, after the infinitive: … te skuif nie?
- Moenie dit verkeerd opneem nie, maar … (Do not take this the wrong way, but …):
- Softens a direct critique in advance.
- verkeerd opneem (to take the wrong way) is a separable verb. After the negative imperative moenie, the undivided infinitive opneem goes to the end of the first clause, followed by the closing nie.
- If the clause after maar is positive, it needs no further nie: … maar die gang is te smal.
- If that clause is negated, it takes its own nie … nie pair: … maar die plan is nie heeltemal prakties nie (not completely practical).
| Would it not be better to move the entrance? | Sou dit nie beter wees om die ingang te skuif nie? |
| Would it not be better to choose larger windows? | Sou dit nie beter wees om groter vensters te kies nie? |
| Do not take this the wrong way, but the corridor is too narrow. | Moenie dit verkeerd opneem nie, maar die gang is te smal. |
| Do not take this the wrong way, but the plan is not completely practical. | Moenie dit verkeerd opneem nie, maar die plan is nie heeltemal prakties nie. |
Quick summary
| Routine | Meaning | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Daar is beslis meriete in …, maar … | There is certainly merit in …, but … | Praise first, then the drawback |
| Daar is nog ruimte vir verbetering wat … betref | There is still room for improvement regarding … | Flag a specific weak aspect |
| Sou dit nie beter wees om … te … nie? | Would it not be better to …? | Suggest a change politely |
| Moenie dit verkeerd opneem nie, maar … | Do not take this the wrong way, but … | Cushion blunt criticism |
Your questions are stored by us to improve Elon.io