Sem a locomotiva, não adianta culpar o maquinista.

Questions & Answers about Sem a locomotiva, não adianta culpar o maquinista.

How does não adianta come to mean "it is no use," and why is it followed by the infinitive culpar?
Literally, adiantar means to move forward or advance. In the negative (não adianta), the idea is that an action won't move things forward or do any good—in other words, "it's no use" or "there's no point." While English often uses an -ing form here ("blaming"), Portuguese uses the infinitive (culpar). Grammatically, the phrase culpar o maquinista acts as the subject of adianta ("to blame the train driver doesn't help"), which is why adianta stays in the third-person singular.
How would the sentence change if I wanted to specify who is blaming the train driver?
You just place the subject directly before the infinitive, turning it into a personal infinitive when the subject takes a plural ending. You do not need to add que or switch to the subjunctive: Não adianta você culpar o maquinista (It's no use you blaming the train driver), Não adianta a gente culpar o maquinista (It's no use us blaming the train driver), or Não adianta eles culparem o maquinista (It's no use them blaming the train driver, using the personal infinitive ending -em).
Why does o maquinista take a masculine article when it ends in -a, and how is it different from motorista?
Nouns ending in -ista (which usually describe professions, roles, or beliefs) use the same form for both genders, so only the article and adjectives change: o maquinista for a man and a maquinista for a woman. As for the vocabulary, motorista is used for someone who drives road vehicles like cars, buses, and trucks, whereas maquinista is the specific word for someone who operates a train (o trem) or subway (o metrô).
Why is the article a used in sem a locomotiva when sem often drops the article?
After sem, you leave out the article when talking about lacking something in general, such as um trem sem locomotiva (a train without a locomotive). Here, the definite article a is included because the speaker has a specific engine in mind ("without the locomotive" for that particular train), matching the specific driver (o maquinista).

Learn Sem a locomotiva, não adianta culpar o maquinista and more in Portuguese

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
  • ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
  • ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free