In English, verbs like say, warn, remind, and insist change structure depending on whether you are reporting a fact (He warned that the stairs are clear) or giving an instruction (He told us to go down). Brazilian Portuguese makes a similar distinction after communication verbs like dizer (to say / to tell), falar (to say / to tell), avisar (to warn / to let know), lembrar (to remember / to remind), and insistir (to insist). For a fact, use que + indicative. For an order, use para + infinitive or que + subjunctive.
Useful words: a simulação (simulation / drill), a fumaça (smoke), o incêndio (fire / blaze), o extintor (fire extinguisher), a mangueira (hose), ferido / ferida (injured), a maca (stretcher), a sirene (siren), evacuar (to evacuate), a máscara (mask).
Reporting Facts: que + Indicative
When you report a statement, observation, or piece of information as a fact, follow the communication verb with que and a verb in the indicative mood (ordinary present, past, or future tenses):
- dizer que / falar que: In everyday Brazilian Portuguese, falar que is used right alongside dizer que to mean to say that.
- avisar que: to warn that or to let [someone] know that something is true.
- lembrar que: to remember that, or to point out / remind someone that something is true.
- insistir que: the speaker insists that a fact is true.
Here are avisar que, dizer que, and falar que reporting facts during a drill (estar prestes a = to be about to):
And here are lembrar que and insistir que stating facts:
Giving Orders and Instructions: para + Infinitive
When dizer, falar, avisar, or lembrar relays an order or instruction (told us to..., warned everyone to..., reminded us to...), everyday Brazilian Portuguese usually uses para + infinitive:
- Meaning shift with lembrar: lembrar que
- indicative recalls or points out a fact (I remember that...). lembrar para
- infinitive tells someone what to do (reminded [us] to...).
- Showing who must act (personal infinitive): After para, Portuguese often uses the personal infinitive to make clear who receives the order:
- For você or a singular noun, the form looks like the plain infinitive (para você colocar, told you to put on).
- For nós (us), add -mos (para evacuarmos, told us to evacuate; para trazermos, reminded us to bring). The -mos ending already shows who acts, so nós is usually left out.
- For vocês, eles / elas, or todos (everyone), add -em (para todos evacuarem, for everyone to evacuate).
Here are dizer para and falar para relaying instructions:
And here are avisar para and lembrar para (assim que a sirene tocar = as soon as the siren sounds; antes que o incêndio se espalhe = before the fire spreads):
Giving Orders: que + Subjunctive
An order can also be relayed with que + subjunctive. With insistir, this is the most common way to demand an action. With dizer, falar, avisar, and lembrar, it is also correct but sounds more formal than para + infinitive (Ela diz que você coloque a máscara. = She says you should put on the mask.). insistir para + infinitive also exists (Ela insiste para sermos rápidos.).
After que, the mood of the verb signals the meaning:
- Fact vs. command: Carlos insiste que a sirene ainda não tocou has the indicative tocou, so Carlos is asserting a fact. A coordenadora insiste que todos mantenham a máscara has the subjunctive mantenham, so she is demanding an action. In the same way, Ela diz que você coloca a máscara reports a fact (says that you put it on), while Ela diz que você coloque a máscara is an order.
- Key subjunctive forms: mantenham (from manter, to keep), segurem (from segurar, to hold), and sejamos (from ser, to be).
Speakers often report a fact and give an order in the same sentence:
Summary
| Verb | Reporting a Fact (que + Indicative) | Giving an Order (para + Infinitive / que + Subjunctive) |
|---|
| dizer | Ela diz que é só uma simulação. (She says that it is just a drill.) | O comandante disse para evacuarmos. (The commander told us to evacuate.) |
| falar | Você falou que estão prontos? (Did you say that they are ready?) | Ela falou para você colocar a máscara. (She told you to put on the mask.) |
| avisar | Ele avisa que a escada está livre. (He warns that the stairs are clear.) | Avise para todos evacuarem. (Warn everyone to evacuate.) |
| lembrar | Eu lembro que ele está na maca. (I remember that he is on the stretcher.) | Ana lembrou para trazermos o extintor. (Ana reminded us to bring the extinguisher.) |
| insistir | Carlos insiste que a sirene não tocou. (Carlos insists that the siren didn't sound.) | O chefe insiste que vocês segurem a mangueira. (The boss insists that you hold the hose.) |