Indirect questions inside statements and requests
You can embed a question inside a statement or request. Use verbs like saber ("to know"), ver ("to see"), perguntar ("to ask"), and revelar ("to reveal"), or a request like Me diga... ("Tell me..."). In casual speech you'll also hear Me diz.... The embedded clause uses normal subject + verb order and normally takes an indicative verb:
- como ("how"), quem ("who"), and onde ("where") introduce the clause directly: Ninguém sabe como o documento sumiu ("Nobody knows how the document disappeared").
- If the verb or time expression needs a preposition, put the preposition right in front of the question word. Unlike English, Portuguese never leaves it at the end of the sentence. Examples: a que horas ("at what time") and para quem ("who ... to", with ligar para, "to call").
Key mystery words: sumir ("to disappear / go missing"), o mistério ("the mystery"), suspeito / suspeita ("suspicious"), a pista ("the clue").
| Nobody knows how the document disappeared from the drawer. | Ninguém sabe como o documento sumiu da gaveta. |
| It is still a mystery, because nobody saw who left the suspicious package in the office. | Ainda é um mistério, pois ninguém viu quem deixou o pacote suspeito no escritório. |
| Marina asked me what time her watch disappeared. | A Marina me perguntou a que horas o relógio dela sumiu. |
| This clue will reveal where the thief hid the bag. | Essa pista vai revelar onde o ladrão escondeu a bolsa. |
| The doorman did not reveal who that suspicious man called. | O porteiro não revelou para quem aquele homem suspeito ligou. |
| Tell me what time the document disappeared and who was there. | Me diga a que horas o documento sumiu e quem estava lá. |
Question words with an infinitive: não sei o que fazer
Sometimes the person wondering or deciding is also the one who will act. Then a question word can go straight before an infinitive, much like English "what to do" or "where to go":
- o que
- infinitive ("what to..."): não sei o que fazer ("I don't know what to do"), o que investigar ("what to investigate")
- como
- infinitive ("how to..."): como investigar ("how to investigate")
- onde / para onde
- infinitive ("where to..."): onde procurar ("where to look"), para onde ir ("where to go", with para for a destination)
- com quem
- infinitive: com quem falar ("who to talk to"). Again, the preposition goes before quem, not at the end as in English.
| Clara is confused and doesn't know what to investigate now. | A Clara está confusa e não sabe o que investigar agora. |
| We need to decide how to investigate this clue this afternoon. | Precisamos decidir como investigar essa pista hoje à tarde. |
| Lucas got so confused that he didn't know where to go. | O Lucas ficou tão confuso que não sabia para onde ir. |
| We still don't know who to talk to in order to solve the mystery. | Ainda não sabemos com quem falar para resolver o mistério. |
Asking and answering "why": por que, porque, and por quê
Portuguese spells "why" and "because" differently depending on their role and position:
- por que (two words, no accent) means "why" when followed by the rest of the question. This works in a direct question (Por que a porta estava aberta?) and in an indirect one (Não entendo por que ela saiu).
- porque (one word, no accent) means "because" and introduces a reason. In everyday speech, por que and porque usually sound the same.
- por quê (two words, with a circumflex) means "why" right before a pause: at the end of a sentence, or alone as a one-word question. There, quê is stressed, and the circumflex marks it.
| I don't understand why she left without giving any explanation. | Não entendo por que ela saiu sem dar nenhuma explicação. |
| Why was the door open? Because Bia forgot to lock it. | Por que a porta estava aberta? Porque a Bia esqueceu de trancar. |
| The light went out suddenly, but nobody knows why. | A luz apagou de repente, mas ninguém sabe por quê. |
| Are you looking for clues in the garage? Why? | Você está procurando pistas na garagem? Por quê? |
The noun "the reason": o porquê and the four forms compared
The fourth form is o porquê (one word, with a circumflex). It is a masculine noun meaning "the reason" or "the why" (plural os porquês):
- As a noun, it normally comes after an article or determiner (o porquê, um porquê, esse porquê).
- For "the reason for...", add de, which contracts with articles and demonstratives: o porquê desse segredo ("the reason for this secret").
| Form | Meaning and role | Example |
|---|---|---|
| por que | "why" followed by the rest of the question (direct or indirect) | Não sei por que ela sumiu. |
| por quê | "why" at the end of a clause or alone | Ninguém sabe por quê. / Por quê? |
| porque | "because", introducing a reason | Porque a Bia esqueceu de trancar. |
| o porquê | "the reason / the why" (masculine noun) | Quero entender o porquê de tanta confusão. |
| We need a clear explanation to understand the reason for so much confusion. | Precisamos de uma explicação clara para entender o porquê de tanta confusão. |
| Tell me the reason for this secret, because I want to know the truth. | Me diga o porquê desse segredo, porque eu quero saber a verdade. |
| Nobody knows why she disappeared or where to look. | Ninguém sabe por que ela sumiu nem onde procurar. |
| We need to decide what to do because nobody explains the reason why. | Precisamos decidir o que fazer porque ninguém explica o porquê. |
