Modal verbs for deduction (må være, må ha, kan ha)

Modal verbs like må (must), kan (can / could / may), and vil (will) do more than express obligation, ability, or desire. You also use them to make logical deductions, weigh possibilities, and predict outcomes based on clues.

For the present or future, follow the modal verb with a bare infinitive (without å). To speculate about the past, follow the modal verb with ha + past participle.

MeaningPresent / Future (modal + infinitive)Past (modal + ha + past participle)
Logical conclusion (must)må være (must be)må ha vært (must have been)
Possibility (could / may / might)kan være (can / could / may be)kan ha vært (could / may have been)
Prediction (will)vil være (will be)(not covered in this lesson)

Present deductions and predictions (må være, kan være, vil være)

When examining evidence in the present, choose the modal verb that matches how certain you are:

  • må være (must be) expresses a strong logical deduction: Ringen er så tung at gullet må være ekte (The ring is so heavy that the gold must be real).
  • kan være (can be / could be / may be) expresses a possibility or guess, both in statements and in questions (Kan dette være ...?). Notice that English often uses could or might for present possibility, while Norwegian usually uses the present tense kan.
  • vil være (from å ville, present vil) expresses a confident prediction about what will be true (will be). When a sentence begins with a conditional clause (Hvis gjenstanden er ekte, ...), remember to invert the verb and subject in the main clause (... vil den være verdifull).

Adjectives after være still agree with the subject: verdifull (valuable) takes -t with neuter singular subjects (Sølv er verdifullt), while adjectives ending in -e like ekte (real / genuine) stay unchanged (Gullet er ekte).

Useful words: en gjenstand (an object / item, gjenstanden), et metall (a metal, metallet), gull (gold, gullet), sølv (silver, sølvet), and et våpen (a weapon, våpenet).

This round object in the ground must be an old coin.
Denne runde gjenstanden i jorda må være en gammel mynt.
The metal is shining in the sun, so it could be gold.
Metallet skinner i sola, så det kan være gull.
The ring is so heavy that the gold must be real.
Ringen er så tung at gullet må være ekte.
This old silver will be very valuable to the museum.
Dette gamle sølvet vil være veldig verdifullt for museet.
If the object is genuine, it will be valuable.
Hvis gjenstanden er ekte, vil den være verdifull.
Could this be an old weapon, or is it a tool?
Kan dette være et gammelt våpen, eller er det et verktøy?

Speculating about the past (må ha, kan ha + past participle)

To deduce or guess what happened in the past, combine må ha (must have) or kan ha (could have / may have / might have) with the past participle:

  • må ha
    • past participle expresses a firm conclusion about the past: Noen må ha glemt dette (Someone must have forgotten this).
  • kan ha
    • past participle expresses a past possibility: De kan ha brukt krukka (They may have used the jar).
  • In an indirect question where hva (what) is the subject of the clause, add som right after hva: Forskeren lurer på hva som kan ha skjedd (The researcher wonders what could have happened).

Key verbs and past participles in this section:

  • å tilhøre (to belong to) → har tilhørt (takes a direct object with no preposition in Norwegian: må ha tilhørt kongen)
  • å glemme (to forget) → har glemt
  • å være (to be) → har vært
  • å skje (to happen) → har skjedd
  • å gjemme (to hide) → har gjemt
  • å bruke (to use) → har brukt
  • å ligge (to lie / be located) → har ligget

Useful words: en mur (a stone or brick wall, muren), en rest (a remainder, resten — the rest), and ei krukke (a jar / pot, krukka).

The heavy weapon must have belonged to the young king.
Det tunge våpenet må ha tilhørt den unge kongen.
The silver in the box may have belonged to the queen herself.
Sølvet i esken kan ha tilhørt dronningen selv.
Someone must have forgotten this metal by the campfire.
Noen må ha glemt dette metallet ved bålet.
This thick wall must have been very high.
Denne tykke muren må ha vært veldig høy.
The researcher wonders what could have happened to the rest of the wall.
Forskeren lurer på hva som kan ha skjedd med resten av muren.
She must have hidden the rest of the treasure under the stone.
Hun må ha gjemt resten av skatten under steinen.
He thinks that they may have used the jar to store food.
Han tror at de kan ha brukt krukka til å lagre mat.
These objects must have lain behind the wall for several hundred years.
Disse gjenstandene må ha ligget bak muren i flere hundre år.

Contributors